Skip to content

Integrate R002C, R002D, R002E and R0030 through existing owners - #251

Draft
theislampill wants to merge 31 commits into
mainfrom
pro/r002c-r002d-r002e-r0030-20261023
Draft

theislampill wants to merge 31 commits into
mainfrom
pro/r002c-r002d-r002e-r0030-20261023

Conversation

@theislampill

@theislampill theislampill commented Oct 23, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Purpose and source

Advance four original Rockstars through one integration branch and one draft PR. Refs #196 (R002C), #197 (R002D), #198 (R002E), and #200 (R0030). These references are non-closing; merge, release and individual issue acceptance remain outside this draft's claim.

  • Branch: pro/r002c-r002d-r002e-r0030-20261023
  • Candidate: 488e5d14fc6fb4901690213a8b92d22ac7025ef9
  • Tree: 0d9483678bf013451d57fd5d4a963fbc9fa01b09
  • Recovered main: e78f7cb21af4197d490f10bc95917a4c75f748aa, tree e0263d4455549a47243d82f45cf31101c6b94df2
  • Nine logical commits, 26 changed files. Final source-manifest SHA-256: 75fd084423c780cd927c33f6a362b6c9590e07f2390a669ccb5d7d82c72fb44b.

Problem and implementation

Current-source witnesses showed admission without dependency/recovery capacity, stale authority reaching a cooperating mutation, a blocking FIFO fence read, execution of altered same-size projection bytes, and handoff completeness despite missing or replaced evidence. Independent review also reproduced a mutable packet reread and a live state-path replacement. The original failures are retained.

  • R0030 P34 / D48-C04: extend the existing planning/action-selection owner with semantic retry eligibility, deadline/queue-age checks, downstream capacity and recovery headroom. Low-consequence direct work remains cheap. Worker slots and queue depth cannot substitute for dependency observations.
  • R0030 P37 / D48-C02: bind request, target preimage, controller, generation and verified receipt at the actual apply-observed-mutation.sh sink. A verify-only native Git prepared reference transaction excludes protocol-cooperating authority publication through target effects, rollback and the durable terminal target journal. The final result is persisted after guard release and includes its outcome. Guard loss or uncertain release retains UNKNOWN, manual reconciliation, journals and auxiliary-effect accounting. No authority reference is rewritten.
  • R0030 C03 compatibility: ordinary result, authority and journal records retain their exact v2 contracts. Protected records explicitly use v3 through one shared formatter. Early protected refusals report NOT_EVALUATED and a null guard; a late carrier produces v3 UNKNOWN while retaining the earlier ordinary v2 authority. The original R0036 consumer is unchanged.
  • R002E: restore the stronger retained conditional security instructions and nine-case fixture. The projection loader verifies a fixed source-owned length/digest and compiles the same captured buffer, including cache checks. The reserved shell-to-companion edge and original actual-policy integration remain explicit.
  • R002D: capture the handoff packet once for hashing and consumption. Receiver-required state references receive current commit/digest and descriptor/live-path verification. Ordinary no-Python handoffs, semantic acceptance and Class-3 authority retain their separate contracts. Existing P007/P012/P032 owners were reconciled without a new framework.
  • R002C: preserve the accepted 68-property crosswalk and source/helper evidence; integrate through the same consequence/control owners. No duplicate safety profile or helper was added.

The existing governor, four children, builders, installers and canonical CI registry remain the owners. The new distributed aggregate appears once in that registry.

Source verification and independent review

Completed focused evidence:

Family Actual evidence
Action selection 150 engineering, 15 verifier, 9 security and 76 distributed boundary controls passed
Distributed aggregate Original 3 fencing and 6 admission cells retained; initial 39 protected-boundary controls passed
Final protected schema/fence bank 43/43 passed, including four added ordinary/protected early-result controls; 166.921 seconds
Unchanged R0036 mutation consumer Baseline PASS; published pre-repair candidate RED; repaired source PASS, 147.773 seconds
Projection source custody 10 methods passed, including drift, invalid pins, cache reuse and source/plugin/standalone layouts
Handoff owner Original family plus packet-capture and path-replacement controls passed
Additional independent probes Retained v3 UNKNOWN journal and mixed historical-v2-authority/v3-UNKNOWN result passed; durable result equals stdout; target unchanged

Complete integration review SHA-256: 5b3a20eb84bcd6330d5ee200003eee06a0a40ecc6684dc179aed4ebbf4c6621d. Two fixture addenda preserve unchanged oracle semantics. The final six-file schema addendum has no unresolved blocking source finding, SHA-256 9365286bfa296f3feadff93ddfd406cca2f8088e0c923a423fbe4f32a513dbc0; it independently binds all 26 manifest entries and exact prepared tree to the published candidate. This is source review, not original issue certification or a GitHub human approval.

Exact final qualification

Hosted canonical validation completed SUCCESS at 2026-10-23T12:30:02Z in run 39948989023, job 120398535728. Its actual checkout was synthetic merge f91859537dbce59b00d6c9347034feee4d7599ec, whose verified parents are main e78f7cb and candidate 488e5d14, and whose tree is exactly the candidate tree 0d9483678bf013451d57fd5d4a963fbc9fa01b09. Full package validation, 64 canonical transaction tests and 70 reader tests passed. This is exact candidate-tree CI, not literal candidate-commit execution. Log SHA-256: c2e99487060261681ba6bff08470d331ab3f5b0fa1b8162a3b9ecf94be623b88. Final packages reproduce identically in two clean builds: plugin 410,853 bytes, SHA-256 da23dd2004a457d6415b6443b0a5d091a369d6a96deb1e6c51dc0da2301e852a; standalone 406,431 bytes, SHA-256 8fd7c6a2f278a7f77ff88910a007b93cefcd52cbff14dbdbf2906e729de4c75d. Headroom is 47,899 / 52,321 bytes against the unchanged 458,752-byte cap and 2,000-byte reserve. All four official temporary Codex/Claude plugin/standalone copies pass complete parity (71/71 plugin, 68/68 standalone). Fresh installed current/stale/cheap/projection controls pass 8/8, including exact ordinary v2 and protected v3 result/authority shapes. Installed successful transactions remove their journals, so retained journal shape remains covered by the adverse source probes, not falsely credited to this installed run.

Three prior hosted failures are retained and resolved at their demonstrated owners:

  1. Semantic-preservation fixtures still pinned pre-change owner hashes. Eighteen identity fields were rebound; all 21 evaluator/oracle meanings and semantic anchor blocks were preserved and independently compared.
  2. A deliberate historical e1 continuity fixture lacked the scanner's existing legacy annotation. Only the comment changed; AST and non-comment tokens remained identical.
  3. The new protected fields reused a fixed v2 schema. This was an actual source compatibility defect. The repair versions protected records and passes the original unchanged consumer; no consumer assertion was relaxed.

An earlier local canonical wrapper was interrupted after two reader FAIL observations and has no recovered terminal result. A later complete unchanged 32c local reader bank had one failure: test_actual_roadmap_absence_between_separate_reads_refuses did not raise ReaderError. The original log did not capture the deletion hook, actual return or output state; it does not establish fail-open. Original log SHA-256 d032d2f22a78d117a3ebb3fbc715185f7635746a054f49f1c3f215ded4aac53e and retained fixtures remain. A fresh unchanged six-case prefix, a passive-traced original singleton and the full hosted reader bank passed, but the earlier cause remains unresolved. No source/assertion repair was invented. A recurrence must capture discovery, owner argv/results, deletion, actual return/exception and pre-cleanup output/state.

The separate 49-command suffix passed 34 commands (two previously unexecuted canonical banks plus 32 registered wrappers), then stopped at eval-harness because its existing fixture interprets any .git file as a WSL layout. The original failure is retained. A fresh standalone detached native clone at unchanged 32c/tree9033 ran only the failed eval plus 14 previously unexecuted wrappers: 15/15 commands exited 0 in 1,054.117 seconds, with unchanged registry/test bytes and clean final checkout. The wrapper counts across these separate local runs are 66/67 with PASS observations; the original canonical wrapper retains its reader RED. This is not one local whole-suite PASS. Platform-specific skipped cases remain skipped. Tail receipt SHA-256 64f396b96aa1e08aa56b51d818326be8b72ac46688fd469cb63d5d4c8e15ee62; log SHA-256 27fff05af41b0771a3dc6f2049801370fc9f007497a7886f1ed88380256428cb; terminal-preservation SHA-256 3134660f8e2a7ff679c058686f30f52d3fb429a9120949842823a0869392ed9c. Original 800 reader files remain unchanged; the prior suffix's ignored run-root residue remains retained.

Local socket denial, process reaping, missing pinned dependency and linked-worktree fixture layout failures were separated from source failures. Their original witnesses remain; corrected environments did not weaken product assertions.

Installed interpretation and ActiveGraph evidence

Five fresh agents executed frozen ordinary installed interpretation missions with independent scoring: 19 supported criteria, one unverified inspection act, no established behavioral failure. Actual owner-load events were not independently sealed. These runs remain scoped advisory evidence on their original installed artifact, not full prompt-independent activation-family or native-discovery PASS.

Exact ActiveGraph 1.10.0 was recovered, installed in isolation and passed all 14 unchanged offline library controls. Both 1.10.0 and 1.12.0 passed five candidate-bound offline stages at 32c361f: artifact-checking mission, strict replay, compaction, snapshot replay and closed-run retirement. All original events were retained. Those completed version-specific receipts are preserved. Both versions also passed all five fresh final-candidate stages at 488e5d14, binding the new packages, all 139 installed archive files and eight fresh helper controls. Final 1.10.0 receipt SHA-256 6351f9d58ab9cb917657c171eb6268a8d7c63547e705b20f4c10b0ef24a36ad8; 1.12.0 receipt SHA-256 bd3e97e77cc7cd3c14437b0c1299dca9a90cd631e2fd37f6eef2427c1432c16f. They do not establish a supported native model runner, independent broker-secret/journal custody, or full protected self-dogfood.

Four independent acceptance verdicts

Original issue Preserved and newly achieved Remaining original acceptance
R002C / #196 — OPEN, partial qualification 68 properties and accepted source/crosswalk/helper work preserved; common consequence/control composition and bounded installed interpretation Complete exact-final ordinary installed material/cheap/distractor/boundary/held-out family with independently observed owner loads; authentic effects, erroneous-boundary and recovery acceptance
R002D / #197 — OPEN, portable work advanced 72 properties; accepted four-child/package/CI/DAG/release composition; receiver custody repair; P007/P012/P032 source dispositions; actual 1.10.0 offline execution Full final-candidate authenticated self-dogfood and actual P039 intended-use evidence. Conditional same-extension P016/P017 is not triggered by this bounded correctness claim; prospective SSS/AMA research is unadmitted
R002E / #198 — OPEN, component qualification 60 properties; stronger conditional guidance; exact executed projection-buffer binding and installed component controls Full original SECURITY_PROFILE_TRIGGER_AND_CHEAP_PATH; exact private crosswalk, policy/held-out/SOURCE_SUBJECT inputs; actual-purpose integration; reserved shell custody; native authenticated receiving effects and applicable domain boundaries
R0030 / #200 — OPEN, P34/P37 source controls demonstrated 54 properties, 98 R&M and 133 Formal outbound edges; independent admission/fence RED/GREEN; v2 compatibility and v3 identity/UNKNOWN evidence Final package/installed controls and full hosted candidate-tree CI passed within their stated scope. Applicable C08 behavior and C09 authentic external authority/effect/recovery. P53/D48-O01 remains a separate owner decision

The green combined CI is regression evidence and is not four original acceptance certificates.

Concurrent owners and proof limits

Current readback retains main e78f7cb and this PR at 488e5d14. Neither concurrent branch/PR was written.

R0035 / PR246: current head 0ded1c62771c91729f8ac3c75a7066ad4eb9d682, tree 8a461424d6b510b7c82dedc49d57152a568781d6. The unpublished pairwise proposal tree e9bf7f6dc977312656e76ce1768dcf96b8574ebb resolves three shared paths/two text conflicts, preserving the disjoint 18+14 semantic SHA leaves and all 21 oracles. A real stale companion-profile conflict was reproduced and repaired only by exact size/hash propagation through existing transport/receiver/compiler owners. Focused semantic, registry, helper, graph-consumer and10 receiver controls passed. Both deterministic archive pairs are rejected: plugin 466,205 and standalone 461,683 bytes exceed the unchanged 458,752 cap by 7,453/2,931, or 9,453/4,931 short including reserve. The standalone production refusal was executed. Inventories correctly record HEAD 488/tree 0d948/dirty; the external manifest binds the staged proposal, and no commit was created. Report SHA-256 d4eb9a953086cc69e5651c4519558960c521aecfe62e3b2413d74d427047af87. This PR's own clean packages remain separately qualified.

R0039 / PR252: current head 36df2f257666a461ea7d2450d43bc5daff47c1c2, tree 3287d0012d796652428185f480b769b5b16811df. Its initial 632-bound proposal retains 25 executed PASS/seven Windows SKIP controls. Successor proposal 3c148aab12175bdb89a05147c71794f45858fffc has five shared paths and one companion conflict; unchanged helper/contract/registry checks pass. The required resolution preserves captured-buffer verification AND physical-path cache binding, with a jointly rebound projection pin. The packaged reference changed; older proof is not relabelled as full successor package/native equivalence. Independent successor review SHA-256 02664fe8b9e36d597925bb7ff344312d01b706337af0acc9426b783bdbf2856a.

Three-owner dependency: the two concurrent owners directly overlap in two dispatch files, but R0039 changes all six members of R0035's continuity profile and the transport selector. Read-only retained full-OR archive verification can load a seventh native-input helper and execute the real tokenizer through sys.executable; the present six-source/PATH-only assumption therefore needs actual composition and qualification. The source-byte bound still fits. No triple tree, package or runtime was built, and compressed sizes were not extrapolated. Report SHA-256 d2f3eef6092cce3f2c7b493b7c4366821b75f64c18e28998b4505396a1d4404b.

Reserved shell custody: actual same-size altered companion execution RED was preserved. Independent review rejected the first isolated launcher for cwd import shadowing. A separate V2 removes that regression and passes 15 controls/28 public commands, including full default/safe-path fidelity. Independent report SHA-256 ea38f38ea02bd90e1a80bdbd6a206b300dc2890c09720ce5324f835e86d0c924. It pins a historical composed companion, not either raw PR, and the current helper census rejects inline -c recognition. Actual owner/preimage/pin, checker recognition with negatives, platform/placement and final package/native gates remain. Neither prototype was applied.

These are concrete reviewable proposals and actual refusals; they do not grant an active writer or make pairwise proof into three-owner acceptance.

This integration does not modify claim-run.sh, the canonical projection bytes, continuity instructions, either other workstream's branch/PR or the protected campaign controller. No real-home install, global configuration, release, merge or issue closure occurred. The projection companion change and protected sink must still be composed explicitly with future admitted R0039 changes.

R003A's qualified unsupported-host outcome retains false activation, enforcement and effect flags. It is not positive native admission. This fence protects governed protocol-cooperating writers on the qualified Git files backend; it does not supply an authentic external grant, arbitrary-writer security, universal consensus or a complete distributed runtime.

Continuation and evidence

The accompanying evidence bundle retains original REDs, terminal logs/receipts, source manifests, independent reviews, packages, offline stores and the final successor/coordinator commissions under the repository retention policy. Recover Thread 9.2 must independently verify current source, coordinate actual R0035/R0039 overlaps, and manage issue-by-issue certification and eventual manual closure. Continue this same draft PR; do not split or replace the four original work orders.

Refs #200; preserves shared R002C and R002D consequence controls.
…eap path

Refs #198; composes with R0030 admission in the same owners.
Refs #198; retains R0039 receipt semantics and the reserved shell boundary.
…ences

Refs #197; preserves Class-3 authority and cheap implementation handoffs.
Refs #200 and #198; retains UNKNOWN recovery and ordinary legacy receipts.
Refs #196, #197, #198 and #200. No automatic issue closure; native and owner gates remain separate.
Update only planner and Lean source identity pins after the composed owner changes. Keep all semantic cases, negative oracles, stage bytes, evaluator and reserve requirements unchanged.

Refs #196, #197, #198, #200
Use the existing historical-spelling marker on the intentional v1/e1 receipt fixture. Python syntax, case data and assertions are unchanged, and the existing durable-identity scan retains its canonical-generation gate.

Refs #196, #197, #198, #200
Preserve the original result, authority and journal contracts for ordinary work; explicitly version protected evidence and retain UNKNOWN on late carrier discovery. Keep the original R0036 consumer unchanged, with baseline GREEN, candidate RED and repaired GREEN evidence. Update the existing continuation with exact-version offline ActiveGraph progress.

Refs #196, #197, #198, #200.
Require the existing control envelope for hazardous stopping, apply provenance and proof-proxy refusals to claimed security cheap paths, and bind mutation observations to the captured patch bytes.

Preserve separate R002C/R002D/R002E/R0030 acceptance decisions. Affected wrappers, independent held-outs, six-file integration review and canonical packages passed at the exact source tree. No native effects, full self-dogfood or external exactly-once claim.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Parallel engineering increment: safety/security admission and patch-input custody

Published with expected predecessor 14c018a2e993ec1992ce2dee892725ac825d9c28 and force=false. The branch-ref, PR and commit readbacks now agree:

  • Head: bbf3ef0b04be36720ee49395c7e9c53b27101a2b
  • Tree: a597e7462ac21386ca55fa14cfcbc04f8e6a0da3 (identical to the reviewed six-file local tree)

R002C: hazardous stopping now requires the existing supplied control envelope even when high_consequence is false; ordinary cheap paths remain preserved. The Boolean checker does not independently establish real configuration, state or feedback independence.

R002E: existing provenance and proof-proxy refusals now apply to claimed security cheap envelopes. A genuine no-trigger/no-claim case stays NO_SECURITY_PROFILE. The original 60-property census and nine-case fixture remain unchanged; authentic selected-policy custody and installed-model behaviour remain separate.

R0030: mutation observations now hash the same captured region/replacement bytes used to construct the actual candidate, preventing divergent rereads and the post-capture-removal TypeError. Schemas, fencing and effect authority remain unchanged. This is bounded C03/C05 evidence, not whole C01–C09 acceptance. P53 remains an owner decision.

Qualification: complete affected classifier wrapper 150/150 + 15/15 + 9/9 + 76/76; mutation bank original 4 RED + 2 positive, successor 6/6, and complete affected mutation wrapper PASS. Independent reviews add 14/14 classifier checks and 3/3 actual-helper mutation held-outs. Exact six-file integration review PASS, SHA-256 2c5b8aec860322265a4117e4de84651eb152a0e39915aec1e2980be6826b8c23. Original failures remain preserved.

Canonical package build/checksums and four official isolated staged-copy installations passed. Plugin: 411,007 bytes, SHA-256 02f89ad4a0b296b487872bf59b1b6cbafec661a0048d9d4e1a4cb4ee165e2b88. Standalone: 406,587 bytes, SHA-256 2d181448dc14c83cae4c0591f49afd299998d953579ea57264947fbc68342b04. Installed mutation bytes match reviewed source. These are file-copy/parity checks, not native activation. Fixed cap/reserve unchanged; combined four-source package remains unqualified.

Hosted validate run 40131565578 is in progress. R002D receives no new acceptance credit from this increment; its original semantic requirements and exact-final ActiveGraph obligation continue separately. A separately reproduced R0030 journal/result publication interval is being corrected next. No merge, release, issue closure, external exactly-once claim or other-owner source write occurred.

Keep terminal recovery evidence until a pending result checkpoint persists, then replace the final result atomically. Preserve persistence failures and their effect-accounting limits.

Retain original crash failures, finite recovery controls, independent source/integration review, and separate R0030 acceptance scope.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Published bounded R0030 C05 increment

Head: 46e5591d79b7bb02e07c848ae01a911c1a50d5db
Tree: f63baac35b8b937a7037a98b16d28f343b0dd65b
Parent: bbf3ef0b04be36720ee49395c7e9c53b27101a2b

The terminal-result path previously deleted the transaction journal before a durable result existed. Two actual interruption controls retained that missing-history failure. This increment persists a pending recovery result before journal deletion, then atomically replaces the final result. Persistence and cleanup failures preserve their observed failure disposition instead of re-entering rollback after authority-guard release. Ordinary/protected v2/v3 field contracts are unchanged.

Qualification: seven focused crash/recovery controls passed, along with the existing affected wrapper (98.846 seconds) on the exact final helper. The final test file also contains an eighth separately executed final-directory-fsync characterization and a platform-safe signal constant; the wrapper result is not relabelled as a rerun on that test-file revision. Independent adjacent failure probes and exact four-file integration review passed. Helper SHA-256: f860ac5a3520f029cfcb0c314f30817ad65a492698e8d975ae1a1edf17ac6676. Source review: d418d71415b64cf7bbe8be9d866ec8824bc02a05636665ba28978adf1292be20; integration review: 66599eb6f5776a2d2660c07039cdc2c27c0442b0b7cbc7f30e33f1262d7c1e29.

The sealed candidate passes the canonical package build and all four official isolated staged-copy/helper-parity checks. Plugin: 411,472 bytes, SHA-256 8c49e22da11821d56418b8ec23e93bdd9892703ecfc08ac74c87762542b30c53. Standalone: 407,054 bytes, SHA-256 c3372330c341c829c48ad92188d9fcea07ea019889aec830fd148940d6dd50ad. The 458,752-byte cap and 2,000-byte reserve remain unchanged. This is individual-branch qualification, not combined four-source package qualification or native import proof.

Retained limit: a successful final rename followed by failed transaction-directory fsync can leave a stored COMMITTED record containing the inherited prospective final-fsync effect row while stdout reports F75/RESULT_PERSISTENCE_FAILURE and fewer observed effects. No durable terminal hook fires. The actual failed execution disposition must be consumed; stored status alone is not durable completion evidence. This does not establish power-loss recovery, full C05/C01–C09 acceptance, external exactly-once execution, or P53 authority.

Expected-head non-force publication and public branch/commit/tree readback matched. Hosted CI 40133605411 is in progress. Original failures and substantial source/evidence were checkpointed before publication.

R0035 was refreshed read-only at 377848fc28de60103586ccf4263b97f9d2b6aee8; no source was imported and graph/READY/JOIN ownership is unchanged. R002D's six frozen ordinary interpretation first responses are now with a fresh evaluator; a new candidate-bound ActiveGraph 1.10.0 offline qualification is executing separately. None of these increments closes an original issue.

Record six frozen first-response cases for controlled refinement, justified allocation and early integration, including cheap and negative controls. Preserve exact original package identities and bounded unchanged-source reuse.

Keep native delivery, actual product effects and original self-dogfood acceptance separate.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002D evidence increment and exact-public-candidate qualification — 1e5dc87

Published on this existing draft PR with an expected-head, non-force update:

  • Head: 1e5dc873b11a9d308f6fc554ae9ff4b12103475b
  • Tree: bdeaa5a3fbae34baf6e83b5d0d2aa613bf0735dd
  • Parent: 46e5591d79b7bb02e07c848ae01a911c1a50d5db

The two maintenance documents add the actual six ordinary installed-source interpretation episodes and their independent evaluation. P007, P012 and P032 each received a positive/material case and a bounded cheap-path or authority negative. All six first responses were sealed before a fresh evaluator assessed the frozen criteria. Each case passed its own essential criteria; 53 supporting quotations and 66 input fingerprints were verified. This is cooperative installed-source interpretation evidence, with ambient-guidance and read-receipt limits stated. It does not establish native activation, skill-only causation, real downstream product effects, all 72 properties or whole R002D acceptance.

The exact two-document integration review passed after one ambiguous pronoun was corrected; the initial finding remains retained. Ten consumed owner files are byte-identical across the original execution package and later source candidates, so their existing evidence was reused. Review manifest: 60a9e5a715037c6412f504afa51b8802d467902dbb7e8499a03126cc1549d161.

Fresh final-candidate ActiveGraph 1.10.0 execution

Because the new public commit changes package inventory identity, the earlier candidate's package/run receipt was not relabelled. Fresh canonical archives and four official isolated staged copies were built for the exact public head/tree above. Both archives differ from their predecessors only in IMPLEMENTAUDIT_INVENTORY.json.

Artifact Bytes SHA-256
Plugin 411,472 b290e34ea7aa1f0cce6e0e4d2d28e3f10219e0b6cfc7aec93342886afc996d56
Standalone 407,042 99eadaea9259e0e0394898f32d868de46efcb569505741d8da8d7f6418d3f486

The unchanged 458,752-byte cap and 2,000-byte reserve hold individually. No combined four-source package qualification is implied.

One fresh attempt executed all five bounded offline stages with six subprocess exits of zero:

  1. Eleven real candidate/artifact observations through Runtime, Behavior, run_goal and persistence.
  2. Strict replay plus independent complete-state/artifact comparison; the payload-drift negative demonstrates why strict replay alone is insufficient.
  3. Actual fork pinning, refusal of parent compaction/retirement while pinned, fork retirement and parent compaction.
  4. Snapshot plus a new mission suffix, complete saved-state comparison, and corrupt/missing snapshot refusals.
  5. Separate-process retirement and retained-history verification.

Independent readback verified all 126 packet files, every ordered event dictionary in the retained databases, 24 objects, 22 relations and exactly 22 artifact payloads. Final retention is 55 archived parent events and 28 archived fork events, with no hot events. The fresh runner changes only nine candidate-binding literals; other source text and normalized AST match the previously reviewed corrected runner. The prior 14 library controls and unchanged source qualification were reused, not rerun. Historical failed attempts remain retained, including the unreconstructed in-memory history lost in attempt02.

Fresh independent exact-public-candidate review: PASS, no revision-blocking findings.

  • Execution manifest: 73df368fa68e3abdcf525c04b9459604f1c76153a273aa7c524040077d25e371
  • Execution receipt: 2300767844542bcc53b9087e35d0cdf867bf29e5d6b6320d48f2532431bfd1fb
  • Review report: bf894fd4b830bf72a4d60b5a12f6a00c5b73ccdbab835bceaff8b8d6fecce6e0
  • Review manifest: 34482ea7ef7d97f60b60266c540cd0f4145a69e86d9485befcbcb9d3918bfe2c

The complete new packet, reviews and packages were durably preserved before this receipt. No native broker authentication/custody, general concurrent-retention proof, original 71a7101a acceptance discharge or separately reviewed supersession, issue closure or release readiness is granted.

Hosted CI and continuation

As of 2026-10-24 21:53 UTC:

  • 40131565578, first increment bbf3ef0b: success. Its actual synthetic merge 55ed2bbead48fce70c2a918481001d16c6680377 has the same a597e746 tree as that candidate; the full log is retained.
  • 40133605411, C05 increment 46e5591d: success.
  • 40134949389, current head 1e5dc873: in progress.

These are separate source/CI results, not four original issue closures. R0030's final directory-fsync failure ceiling and P53 authority boundary remain explicit. The next independent R002C work is a finite ordinary installed-task exercise with actual disposable-repository configuration, authority, feedback and recovery observations.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Current-head hosted CI completed successfully

Run 40134949389, job 120994381920, completed successfully at 2026-10-24 22:07:34 UTC for public head 1e5dc873b11a9d308f6fc554ae9ff4b12103475b.

The retained checkout log identifies GitHub's test merge 2d35da95b3d30b5bf07a9213d0e45461113e6be8; direct Git-object readback confirms its tree is exactly bdeaa5a3fbae34baf6e83b5d0d2aa613bf0735dd, matching the public candidate, with parents main e78f7cb2 and this PR head. Whitespace, package-owner JSON and the full verify-package gate passed. Platform skips remain skips.

The complete 390,969-byte job log is retained, SHA-256 439c535d4f9ca166571c98eadc59c0d3efea9d808860f6aa801710d07395ea21. This updates the preceding in-progress CI receipt only; it does not close any of the four original RLGWOs or change their native/authority gates. The separately frozen R002C ordinary-task executions are now underway.

Preserve four sealed first task executions and independent criterion decisions: three PASS and one limited diagnostic GAP-REVISE with successful containment. Bind the actual installed candidate, local effects, failed evidence and native/causal limits without whole-issue closure.

Exact two-document increment independently reviewed; unchanged runtime qualification reused.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002C ordinary local-effect qualification published

Head 39f9e9af11ec1a02d74214d442bad00507c0bc9a, tree 9fd1387060823a88d0b54b956bc0d30a1f650917, parent 1e5dc873b11a9d308f6fc554ae9ff4b12103475b. The expected-old, non-force branch update and public commit/tree readback matched. This increment changes only the two maintenance documents; all runtime source is unchanged.

Four fresh first tasks actually executed against the installed public 1e5dc873 plugin (b290e34ea7aa1f0cce6e0e4d2d28e3f10219e0b6cfc7aec93342886afc996d56). Their original frozen evaluator and all first responses/effects were preserved before assessment:

  • A PASS: observed the surviving old batch after pause acknowledgement, cancelled it, verified containment, loaded and separately observed the corrected 30-day configuration/feedback before authorized restart, and actually ran one new batch without losing either record.
  • B GAP-REVISE on essential 2: preserved containment, grants, records and a precise recovery handoff, but did not read the accessible stale loaded configuration. This is a diagnostic-evidence gap, not an unsafe restart or established maintained-product defect. No oracle relaxation or rerun for green.
  • C PASS: observed current state and absent restart grant; left the decision with the named owner without operational mutation.
  • D PASS: exact static label correction and existing-check failure-to-success, with operational state unchanged and no expanded safety process.

Assessment report SHA-256 ad2e128066e23bf5d4b313b90e8bc3250119dbbe00f7d7381b824e2202c4bd2c; output manifest 7fcebfd4273ff46b12eacb65b1afdb9b7d3276613f0d7168203c47a2a1f34341. Independent exact-document review PASS: report f9974046b24fbe5e6f727bf8ea57a9b834bec6c0b424384ee6e87a69e75c9a0e, manifest 9004de4c7918acd06a2cda885788446730f3308387d68288513d6452478bdbd5.

The exact-tree local candidate 10788c1fbf286dc64be90e66d3d80348e011c727 produced deterministic plugin/standalone archives of 411,473 / 407,040 bytes. Four official isolated staged copies passed 278 archive-to-installed byte comparisons. Only inventory metadata differs from the previous archives; unchanged component/model/ActiveGraph evidence retains its actual candidate identity. No task, helper bank or native model activation was rerun solely for the documentation commit. Fixed cap 458,752 and reserve 2,000 remain unchanged; the combined four-source package remains unqualified.

Reviewed source, failed evidence, raw first outcomes and independent assessments were preserved durably before publication in checkpoint 13, ZIP SHA-256 5a348354e39c2e83485e0bb9746ebbaedc3f84cdc5380378d908c403165967f0.

The original 68/116 safety census, historical activation, native receiving/effect gates and the four separate original acceptance decisions remain open. Cooperative source reads and local fixture effects do not establish authenticated context delivery, skill-only causation or native authority. New hosted CI is pending observation; preceding head 1e5dc873 has successful hosted CI. R002E's separate first-task assessment and a bounded next R0030 source increment continue independently.

Record three sealed first local executions and their independent frozen-criterion assessments: account ownership repair, current-component refusal with containment, and the reversible help correction. Preserve negative observations, the minor handoff defect and original policy/native/cause limits.

Only the two maintenance documents change. The invocation package remains 1e5dc87; runtime source and all four original acceptance decisions remain separate.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002E ordinary local-task evidence published separately

Head 3ee43680d507399c109511f9905387155cda391f, tree cd229e07334e9f7cf6e29c491ea67e31be7d7639, parent 39f9e9af11ec1a02d74214d442bad00507c0bc9a. Expected-old non-force publication and public ref/commit/tree/PR metadata match. CI 40141458265 is in progress. Only the two maintenance documents change; the separate pending R0030 helper/test correction is excluded.

Three sealed first ordinary local executions on the actual 1e5dc873 plugin were independently assessed against the unchanged pre-execution evaluator:

  • Account ownership: PASS,6 essentials. Actual original other-account disclosure, minimal application guard, unchanged checker observing own200/other403/anonymous401/missing404, bounded caller/session assumptions, retained rollback and assurance limits.
  • Conditional preview recovery: PASS,5 essentials. Green health and offered-byte checksum did not satisfy the fixed component identity. Actual supplied-tool disable and persisted containment were verified; readiness remains exit4 and the matching component is still unavailable. No enable or expectation repin.
  • Display-only help correction: PASS,4 essentials. Actual typo failure-to-success, inspected static data flow and unchanged executable/renderer bytes. The handoff’s minor escaped-newline representation defect is retained; actual preimage and explicit rollback remain unambiguous.

These are three individual bounded findings, not whole R002E acceptance. Assessment report 29aa0b9c6825d30e8603588daed2a074c7fbd6190f6a41b416e28d985c31ab6d; output manifest 92cfce6fcc28264dc79f2d9384c9941039bc6944be0a8c1c6f61c095c2b70130. Fresh exact-document review PASS: report 854ad2ce249d70b13fd9d2f06514fe11b5bd2c21166ecd6ce13328622afa9b55, binding 36e2593bd32b1600bbae404ac1edc0232c2a2a09cf7d30110b6bca617464517d.

Local exact-tree candidate 05faf085ef84a8a56e4742f939edc9ea53ef65c5 produced deterministic archives 411471 / 407041 bytes and four official staged copies with 278 byte comparisons. Only inventory metadata differs from predecessor packages. No model/helper/ActiveGraph bank was replayed or transferred to this later candidate. Prepublication checkpoint15 ZIP SHA-256 b2e36f5cc41c6ac7294f44ebf98089e1b4f3e1e93847f9cc061a06cf0103690b retains the reviewed evidence and packages.

Original60/117 and31/18/4/6/1 accounting, nine canonical cases, ancestor corpus, historical final-package requirement, unavailable original policy/private-crosswalk/held-outs and native principal/transaction/effect receiving obligations remain separate. Fixture requirements are not original approved policy. Cooperative reads and guided task behavior do not establish authenticated context delivery or skill-only causation. Prior R002C’s diagnostic GAP, R002D’s original self-dogfood boundaries and R0030 C01–C09/P53 remain intact.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R0030 completed-effect recording increment published

Head: 81c4e1421cfcc224e6616e53879dc6d91d9ca5e8
Tree: ebb6303a04be55a3460623d1ce358fda82b1e69d
Parent: 3ee43680d507399c109511f9905387155cda391f

The expected-parent, non-force update and public ref/commit/tree/draft-PR readback agree. Hosted validation 40142672853 is in progress; no terminal CI result is claimed.

Implemented behavior

A protected syscall could complete, then the real fixture guard could die before record() ran. The predecessor retained UNKNOWN/manual reconciliation but omitted already-completed effects. The correction separates declared-plan membership from live permission: recording preserves the observed effect, while each subsequent protected operation still checks the live guard. Stage write and fsync now have explicit immediate checks. No authority issuer, fence, fixed v2/v3 schema, protected-effect boundary, retry policy or journal/result ordering was broadened.

Qualification

  • Three original missing-effect REDs are retained: loss after displacement, stage creation and stage writing. The corrected four-case bank and existing pre-effect/cheap controls pass.
  • Independent call-site review and a distinct after-stage-fsync witness pass. Five completed protected rows remain; the next target-link authorization refuses; result stays UNKNOWN/78 with retry false and closure prohibited.
  • One complete affected mutation wrapper passes in 112.216 seconds on source-only candidate 8de7a2ca…; the final candidate differs only in the two additive maintenance records. Exact four-file integration review passes without replaying the behavior bank.
  • Two canonical builds are byte-identical. Plugin: 411,535 bytes, SHA-256 95b7e4b63bd846b20071a7188d293e7401ba4fb464a6330bc1a5efcdc7d440f0. Standalone: 407,105 bytes, SHA-256 48c52d62e489f7198ac79608b54926b9bf7900ccfb1fa4fa103bbb2a3990f104. These artifacts retain local candidate 57646279…, whose tree equals this public tree.
  • Four official isolated copies pass 278 byte/mode comparisons before and after checks. Exactly four installed-helper invocations pass: plugin/standalone unmodified protected positives, and source-derived guard-loss boundaries. They are local fixture executions, not native host sessions.

Independent source report: 4e5f2a140f6a4b4b57c4db0c24e6620adaad8019175285e49174219c27ea89f0. Integration report: 252074b9be3b9e88cadc709a766bc570775466d6f0354b1296b3bbbf8cba107d. Package report: ae14ee004aa6b8abd3b4a9558b4d1ab0c5ecb3a13402f4ec612dd50d821f14e5. Reviewed source and evidence were durably preserved before the update.

Acceptance boundaries

This advances bounded C03 truthful-effect evidence with C02/C05 relevance. The prior final-directory-fsync limitation remains: actual failure reports 97 observed rows while a prospective stored COMMITTED result can contain 98. The unsupported external-writer witness remains unsupported. P53 stays an owner decision; original C01–C09, P34/P37 residuals, native authority, power-loss durability and external exactly-once acceptance remain open. The four RLGWOs remain separate decisions. The combined four-source package remains unqualified; cap 458,752 and reserve 2,000 are unchanged.

The R0035 checkpoint remains read-only at 80f47014…; no source was imported and no graph/READY/JOIN owner was changed. Next: bind warranted final-source offline ActiveGraph observations while the separate PR253 repair-versus-qualification source correction proceeds.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002D exact-public final-source offline ActiveGraph receipt

This evidence is bound to public head 81c4e1421cfcc224e6616e53879dc6d91d9ca5e8, tree ebb6303a04be55a3460623d1ce358fda82b1e69d, parent 3ee43680d507399c109511f9905387155cda391f. No new source commit is needed for this receipt.

One fresh five-stage run completed on the first Runtime attempt: all six subprocesses exited 0 in 3.392469 seconds. Eleven initial artifact observations passed. Strict replay, separate full-state/payload comparison, real fork lineage pins, snapshot plus actual suffix, corrupt/missing snapshot refusals and closed-process retirement passed. The final stores retain 55 parent and 28 fork event dictionaries with zero hot records. These are actual new runtime/store observations, not copied prior outcomes.

The runner changes exactly nine binding lines from the previously independently reviewed runner, with no functional change. The completed fourteen library controls, six ordinary recommendation-only cases and prior source/helper qualifications retain their own identities and were not replayed.

Exact-public packages and independent review

One canonical build binds the inventory to the actual public commit. Plugin: 411,535 bytes, SHA-256 17451aa613f135284ad3fd52615d345cad4f04891ebd514c7f9bf6a42ed05d61. Standalone: 407,116 bytes, SHA-256 15c90d5df88c2248e8c5c39846174a3d9f3cf459e7a5718fcb82eaa0802f2133. Only inventory bytes differ from the previously qualified tree-equivalent local archives. Four official isolated copies pass 278 byte/mode comparisons; unchanged helper executions are reused at their actual earlier identity.

Fresh independent review verified all 162 original package/ActiveGraph members, all six subprocess receipts, the nine binding changes, four installed populations and eight immutable SQLite stores. It accepted the packet only together with additive correction-1. Review report: 7ad4c233e0100bed991427b5d0d5dac80c8c43105358f2121dd66a771e71d29b; review manifest: c07cc8a07183025737928d9b4d461ed3736fa0f1e93c3f7d2e44d4f3fe89f8ff.

Preserved evidence-record finding

AG-R30-F1 identified an inaccurate claim that the initial shallow-history HEAD^ failure's raw outputs were retained. The stored preflight is actually exit 0. Exit 128 survives as the author's earlier collaboration report; its raw failed output is unavailable. The original packet stays immutable. Correction-1 states that limit and retains the real successful preflight, filtered deepen and receiving readback. No failure was reconstructed, and no Runtime or package execution was rerun for the correction.

Corrected report: 1c866adca6efa1a8ef38cca5168e7c265b0c715e05bb5025e030ebeb996fd340; correction manifest: 85a81947b3e0223e01008f0dcc912237e8b9f30c8feb2d59215f23ff0381128d. Original evidence, correction and independent review were durably preserved before this receipt.

The historical 71a7101a combined native self-dogfood obligation remains open. This offline packet does not enact supersession, authenticate native activation or independent broker/journal custody, establish arbitrary payload integrity from strict replay alone, close R002D, or qualify the combined four-source package. Earlier failed attempts and unavailable attempt02 events remain unchanged. P53, R0030's final-directory-fsync limitation and unsupported external-writer boundary remain open. Current-head CI is a separate running gate, not a claimed success.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Current PR251 hosted result and bounded receiving findings

Current head remains 81c4e1421cfcc224e6616e53879dc6d91d9ca5e8, tree ebb6303a04be55a3460623d1ce358fda82b1e69d.

Hosted run 40142672853, job 121017490421 completed SUCCESS at 2026-10-25 00:05:14 UTC. The actual tested merge is 31f6504ff3d297dd280ae718f76783e79842959b, with the exact published tree and parents main e78f7cb21af4197d490f10bc95917a4c75f748aa and this PR head. Provider job/commit records establish this result. The local raw-log copy is explicitly incomplete following an automatic approval rejection; it is not presented as a complete raw receipt.

The exact-public offline ActiveGraph qualification and its preserved evidence-record correction remain as recorded in the independently reviewed receipt. No source, package, ActiveGraph or completed test bank was rerun for this status update.

R0030 final-result receiving boundary

A bounded independent source diagnosis examined the retained final-directory-fsync failure without reenacting it or changing source. Disposition: NO_JUSTIFIED_PATCH from the inspected receiving paths. Report SHA-256: 35c3505452380c744a9427a6ae715f6a9ea7aa70e7741193f4bf91baf1a137b1.

The saved result can contain a prospective final-fsync row marked applied, while the actual live failure returns F75 / RESULT_PERSISTENCE_FAILURE with the observed prefix. That saved representation remains ambiguous; an arbitrary file-only consumer must not be assumed safe.

The inspected shipped paths use different gates: live failure status, preimage drift refusal, retained transaction custody, and refusal of unsupported recovery arguments before effects. No shipped result-file-only completion adapter was found. Also, phase_hook() is a no-op in production: the test's terminal-result-durable marker is fixture instrumentation, not a production durable receipt.

A conservative saved-prefix/pending representation is technically conceivable with existing keys, but would change the current saved/live equality and terminal-effect receiving convention. No speculative one-row relabel, extra self-attestation protocol or external exactly-once claim was introduced. Original C01–C09 and P53/D48-O01 remain separate decisions.

R002C and R002D follow-up scope

R002C case B's accessible loaded-configuration acquisition remains GAP-REVISE, with its containment, authority and handoff observations preserved. Read-only source follow-up found no justified causal product patch. This is not relabeled as a native-host blocker, and the actor was not rerun for green.

A separate, independently preflighted supplemental P032 local stock-report episode was prepared to observe an actual consumer/producer connection beyond the earlier recommendation-only cases. Automatic approval review rejected its first recorded SKILL.md read on authorization-scope grounds, before command execution. The actor stopped; the first response was sealed with zero command receipts and unchanged target files. Disposition: NONVERDICT, with no implementation, test, integration, native or P032 acceptance credit. No workaround or replay was attempted. First-outcome manifest: f9c900b2b7fb017410bc12bda5b11835665f747f9e3f800a0b0aeb286b0c0ac3.

These findings do not combine the four original RLGWOs into one acceptance decision. The original R002E 60-property census, policy custody and applicable receiving boundaries remain intact. Individual package/CI success does not qualify the previously over-budget combined four-source package; cap 458,752 and reserve 2,000 remain fixed.

Preserve the completed effect prefix in protected v3 result files. Keep later
publication effects in actual live output, and retain ordinary v2 compatibility,
all authority/fence decisions, retry refusal and recovery boundaries.

Qualify the original future-effect discriminator, affected partial failures,
an independent late-carrier held-out and both installed package layouts.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Qualified R0030 protected-result increment — separate original acceptance remains open

Published head: 5d03a654b8648ac7c98d95bb9c1e604c7e177b27
Tree: 59388daebf743c9a7e068917a0fb27eec40ef664
Guarded non-force parent: 81c4e1421cfcc224e6616e53879dc6d91d9ca5e8.

The exact remote tree matched the independently reviewed local candidate before commit creation. Public ref, commit parent/tree and existing draft PR were read back. Local alignment changed only the five published paths; the worktree was clean immediately afterward.

Substantive correction

Protected v3 result files now contain the exact effect observations completed at serialization. Their later publication operations enter the live result only after their syscalls return. The correction is confined to persist_result_record(); ordinary v2 compatibility, result schemas/status, plans, generation/fence authority, guard lifetime, retry refusal and recovery behavior remain unchanged.

The original unchanged-source discriminator recorded 86 completed / 90 saved and 92 completed / 98 saved effects. The same discriminator on the correction recorded 86/86 and 92/92, with 98 live effects. The original failed record is preserved.

The historical final-directory-fsync failure remains evidence: originally 98 saved / 97 live; corrected source has 92 saved / 97 live, with exactly five completed later publication rows and no claim for the failed final sync. Saved COMMITTED describes the observed target operation; it does not establish the result file's own durability.

Finite qualification and independent review

  • Four affected guard-loss and eight terminal-custody cases passed. Original ordinary v2 saved/live equality remains qualified. Unchanged campaigns were reused at their actual identities.
  • Fresh ordinary independent review PASS, manifest d38e72e65075501572268b1d610608b1b74f6468b7e5e3f756cffc2e665c9ce4.
  • One distinct actual late-carrier held-out returned UNKNOWN / MANUAL_RECONCILIATION, exit78: 29 completed / 29 saved / 33 live, unchanged target, no protected target or Git-authority effect, retry prohibited. The review driver's original exit1 is preserved: its oracle incorrectly expected a null guard instead of the unchanged NOT_APPLICABLE record. Offline readback of that same call verified the inherited contract and remaining assertions; no second helper invocation occurred.
  • Two canonical builds were byte-identical. Plugin 411662 bytes, SHA256 b826ab69e75c94ed4a5c119217206480a3a94fc6502e5b45432bc77007b8edbe; standalone 407233 bytes, SHA256 1a576c581da410df53c5dd633be4b066ed4ed265cf6a4434a9ed8fe2b2ee4742.
  • Four official isolated installer copies passed 278 byte/mode comparisons. Two unmodified installed-helper calls, one per layout, passed with 92 saved / 98 live and the exact six-row publication suffix. No native activation is inferred.
  • Hosted CI 40150579819 is in progress at this readback. Previous head81c CI40142672853 passed.

Source, original failures, actual outputs, independent review and package evidence were preserved before publication in checkpoint24: 3022686 bytes, SHA256 6b2e43c47ee2d2c1c303bc0ea72023c87e49470761bc9478bec6bfa467589bc8. Package/installed evidence manifest: 6542855a48b4231bd13690602b41e2bb97ac49838552ba85c642119d2a1298d9.

Separate continuation and authority boundaries

The journal's prospective self-publication convention is a separate source obligation now under bounded actual investigation; it is not silently covered by this result correction. No automatic recovery, power-loss durability, external exactly-once execution, noncooperating-writer fence, native grant, P53 decision or full C01–C09 acceptance is established.

R002C's original case-B diagnostic GAP remains. R002E retains its original 60-property census and genuine policy/native receiving gates. R002D's authorised same-fixture continuation produced 11 recorded commands, preserved the original opaque-token pagination failure, corrected the consumer, passed eight tests and produced the exact six inventory rows with producer/README unchanged. Its formal qualification remains NONVERDICT: automatic approval review rejected root's attempted final-response reconstruction/sealing before dispatch. No workaround, actor replay or oracle relaxation occurred. Independent read-only assessment supports the raw E1–E5 observations separately; the prior zero-command refusal also remains sealed NONVERDICT.

All four RLGWOs remain separate original acceptance decisions. Final-source ActiveGraph binding remains distinct from the already qualified version-bound library controls and unavailable original native self-dogfood observations. PR246/252 remain read-only; no R0035 source was imported. Fixed cap458752/reserve2000 are unchanged, and individual packages do not qualify the previously over-budget combined four-source package.

Serialize completed effects for protected v3 journals while preserving v2
compatibility, physical publication order and the existing uncertainty/refusal
contract. Retain the original journal-sync failure and qualify target-history
and custody consumers.

Document the authorised R002D integration observations with its unchanged
formal NONVERDICT after the separate evidence-sealing refusal.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Qualified protected-journal increment

Published d169848d925414d8b8ac25a36a95eee9ec01d748, tree af39ad915a2b51eca5bd67b2628cfa94be748082, by guarded non-force update from 5d03a654b8648ac7c98d95bb9c1e604c7e177b27. Exact remote tree, parent, branch and existing draft PR were read back. The four local published paths align cleanly.

Actual correction and original failure

Protected v3 journals now serialize the completed observation prefix. Ordinary v2 keeps its historical prospective convention. Only persist_journal() changes; physical write/sync/rename order, plans, schemas, identity/fence/guard ownership, status, retry refusal, recovery and cleanup remain unchanged.

The original fault showed 65 completed / 71 serialized observations in the terminal journal. Five later publication operations completed; the 71st directory sync failed, yet the saved journal called it applied. The actual helper already returned UNKNOWN/manual reconciliation. This was an observation defect, not proof of unsafe retry or a false successful return.

Corrected protected snapshots are 23/23, 43/43, 57/57 and 65/65. The selected fault retains 65 saved observations and 81 actual live observations without claiming the failed sync; target history/readback, plan/authority/guard identity and residue survive.

Qualification

  • Original diagnosis and registered predecessor REDs preserved; corrected protected success and fault pass.
  • Existing after-stage-write guard-loss and before-result crash/custody consumers each passed once; recovery/replay controls remain refusals.
  • First ordinary helper succeeded, but its new driver exited1 because it wrongly expected a protected-only fourth journal. That failure remains. Only the route-specific test expectation was corrected; exact final assertions passed offline against the same first call, with no ordinary rerun.
  • Fresh independent ordinary review PASS: report e73b54afe84bc3a2ee318ac98967514979ced19720010872cfffcd173feaa29e, manifest b70e7c49d98ad291d7673a23333441193c22f7d1beacd03e8d1d1b1df08d51bd. Its initial empty-selection R002D readback check is explicitly rejected and preserved; the six-file correction 83e15e07b8e7f2652f71806435be1ba34b12db3914e75ba251a647a5156a9c4b supplies that check. No independent functional rerun was necessary.
  • One canonical build: plugin 411709 bytes, SHA256 3d139f902b83fd1155b0063752ee3f27011fbbe0691d4c250d240f8e59135d1d; standalone 407294 bytes, SHA256 241c82cf99c723faaa912f4ff6ffbf2575126b7dc008976bdb6e7e893b33a05e. Only helper/inventory differ from prior archives. No new two-build reproducibility claim.
  • Four official isolated copies passed 278 byte/mode comparisons. Two unmodified installed helper calls passed, retaining 92 saved / 98 live result effects and all four actual journal publications.
  • Hosted CI 40152076616 is in progress at readback.

Prepublication checkpoint25: 2591567 bytes, SHA256 34fb0e20c079b2425868942654ee6d2656c3ae940aef20b2d67d0ff528a4c8e0; package/install manifest 3e5270e43833d57b877e689022936766b9576d64fe6de561e5a87c731a11485a.

Separate original decisions

The maintenance records now retain R002D's actual authorised warehouse integration observations and its formal NONVERDICT after automatic approval review rejected final response reconstruction/sealing. No response was reconstructed, no oracle was changed, and no actor was replayed. Recorded handoff/source snapshots do not substitute for the missing evidence.

R002C caseB remains GAP-REVISE; a distinct independently preflighted ordinary common-source task is executing once, with no verdict yet. R002E's 60-property census and genuine policy/native receiving requirements remain. Exact-final offline ActiveGraph evidence is separate from the reused version-bound library qualification and original native self-dogfood gate.

Saved COMMITTED is a target/checkpoint disposition, not self-durability. No automatic recovery, power-loss guarantee, native grant, external exactly-once execution, P53 decision, full C01–C09 or whole-issue acceptance follows. Fixed cap/reserve and the combined-package limitation are unchanged. PR246/252 remain read-only; R0035 graph/READY/JOIN ownership is untouched.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Final receiving checkpoint for this independent increment

Hosted CI is now SUCCESS for public head f1332a5, tree 8f45057fc62ffb9572faf5f74210c172fc3a7570, run 40156947120, read at 2026-10-25 03:53:44 UTC. The exact-public ActiveGraph 1.12 qualification and independent review are recorded in comment6393131772.

The newer read-only PR252 head 124e4b5, tree 1e7d4d063a9d18e67dc8db2fda18673b994786a2, has now received a bounded independent compatibility review. It receives the existing projection-custody mechanism into its R0039 population: its helper AST equals current PR251 and its eleven-control fixture is byte-identical. Its route compiler changes only the original14 companion descriptor. No new disjoint false-acceptance or independently executable receiving obligation was found. No source was imported or written on PR252/PR246.

Bindings remain deliberately separate: R0039 projection 125155 / 2fb6495a…, PR251 cooperative projection 92941 / 7989a081…, PR253 native-peer projection 262594 / d0a1ce28…. Neither the R0039 patch nor its pin is an exact current preimage match on the commissioned branches. The 53 static comparisons and 19 verified public source blobs are receiving evidence, not a new behavioral population. Review report SHA-256: 559579c020f4e10ef1dcd60999d9dce2fc4d6cff67a0519f0a8a2b52cb9b30ff.

Reserved shell-to-companion custody, exact owner-compatible composition, C02, actual native authority/effects and final composed-package qualification remain separate. The fixed package cap/reserve remain intact; the prior combined-package over-budget result is not superseded.

All currently identified independent source/qualification increments are handled at their stated scope. This is a bounded frontier disposition, not universal source completeness or four issue closures. R002C case-B GAP, both ordinary-task NONVERDICTs, authentic R002E policy/private-input gates, R0030 C01–C09/P53 and original native R002D self-dogfood remain open. The consolidated return retains implementable owner-dependent work separately from missing native/authority inputs and platform blocks. No Codex, merge, release or issue closure occurred.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Published the independently reviewed four-workstream receiving increment at 45853f9403f5ffaad100df1686fe5320f72e19b7, tree a89bf2fadb155840334efd067ade3658ce8c164c, parent f1332a580faf1289005616fb8ee57969f6e3b745, by guarded expected-head non-force update. Exact public head/tree/parent readback matches; the PR remains draft/open. No new CI run was visible at the first immediate readback. Predecessor CI40156947120 is already SUCCESS and was reused at its exact head.

The two additive maintenance ledgers retain four separate original acceptance decisions:

  • R002C: one genuinely new, prospectively frozen, fully captured cablebench first episode is independently PASS_LOCAL_EPISODE. Twelve actual commands expose the independent local 68 C measurement, repair the permitted map, and correctly retain NO-GO under the unchanged 55 C limit. Original case-B GAP and readiness NONVERDICT remain. Extractor over-attribution and launch-time limits are explicit.
  • R0030: two actual integrated persistence-fault cases consume the real local R0039 fourteen-field receipt and retain truthful saved/live effect prefixes. Journal failure remains UNKNOWN/manual reconciliation; final result failure remains RESULT_PERSISTENCE_FAILURE. Recovery64 is only parser refusal; stale-preimage replay65 has no effects. No durability, external exactly-once, P53 or C01-C09 closure is claimed.
  • R002E: exact reviewed executed-buffer custody proposal is delivered to the R0039 owner in PR252 comment6393556153, without foreign adoption. The exact original six-member frozen security packet is recovered; that does not replace the separately required approved-policy/private-crosswalk bodies still unlocated in the bounded search.
  • R002D: exact-public ActiveGraph1.12 Graph/SQLite/offline evidence is reused without replay or native self-dogfood promotion. The warehouse formal NONVERDICT remains unchanged.

Independent publication claim review: report 7445ecd335f56028ac4d73b64028371d426b1188f5b34aa70df32f555c094505, receipt 5882b92f3c0df4cae06ff9cc88cc0bd867cb4add0d7ea4e297e84d1eb85288fa. All227 insertions are documentary; shipped source is unchanged. Completed actual evidence is preserved in checkpoint38, and this exact reviewed publication candidate was saved before publication in checkpoint39 ZIP 71b58a200feb02095b634d38ed21f5a26b0afe4a15b9d44a11030df2bef2497f.

The real combined source still fails packaging (552283/547677 bytes at dd3c90b/tree9c614f, unchanged458752cap/2000reserve). A further concrete source-loader/currentness composition repair is now frozen and undergoing actual portable qualification; no native admission, larger redesign impossibility or Pro exhaustion is inferred. Engineering continues across the authorised isolated integration candidates; no merge, release, issue closure or Codex launch.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002E: qualified recovery of all 60 embedded source rows; original custody gates remain open

The current public PR head remains 45853f9403f5ffaad100df1686fe5320f72e19b7, tree a89bf2fadb155840334efd067ade3658ce8c164c. This is an additive source-receiving result, with no new behavioral or original-issue acceptance verdict.

The actual canonical research aggregate was materialized and inspected: 36,678,810 bytes, SHA-256 9dd91f7f84f3bdd00a98e50aca31a9bdc965381ab508728393bf6f2e275cbeee. It contains all 60 SSD_SECURITY source-schema rows P01–P60. The earlier text-search result supplied no indexed lines; it did not establish absence of the embedded records.

The retained derivative is 1,325,517 bytes, SHA-256 5ba5dc869184ce59aeef7f29b94eb8ab71c1fa88e64add4e3006a593ba139d0f. Independent review confirms complete equality of all 60 objects and their 45 fields, including original grades and dispositions, and confirms each aggregate-declared canonical row hash. All 129 literal captures independently match their structural JSON pointers, byte offsets and digests. These identity checks are not 60 new behavioral PASS results.

Independent source-receiving review: report 0f18f3724edb2f5730d6a17396028a386953ee84f32a45d95673e5b1f6dae577; receipt 55a33b01bf3d7ba6bc94fb927f2be87abb1d497911ae93a423bedc398694deba. No extractor, product test or earlier actor was replayed by that review.

The exact original 1,184,551-byte crosswalk, SHA-256 61b3d172a6d7d0baf2caee2a1406a65e27c2282f96f8474cd8d4893a59cf54b3, remains cited by the aggregate rather than received as original whole-file bytes. The approved-policy body and approval/custody binding for SHA-256 d2114a8dc618d7405901ebe625d1f08e0c7591d75739bb67c4ddef256940e23c also remain unavailable in the inspected material. No original envelope, approval, policy content or private held-out has been reconstructed. The received rows can now inform further applicable original discriminators while those distinct gates remain open.

Exact combined-source package result

The current disposable integration candidate is 095eb55a97015356939e1988b139eb116fe9b21b, tree db1bec89c09c2093f643e621943363c8d23146e3. Its reproducible Git bundle is 207,004 bytes, SHA-256 ebf391df32aad3462620d28a48ec38e34b68e575169d0b190999dba89b384268, requiring public f1332a580faf1289005616fb8ee57969f6e3b745. It includes the reviewed local shell-custody and R35 source-profile proposals; neither is represented as adopted on another owner's branch.

One actual canonical build completed with exit 1. Independent measurement confirms:

Projection Actual bytes SHA-256 Reduction required, including the unchanged reserve
Plugin, 75 members 552,309 105fed5949d155d17ff697462338048a718de0aa3acfa442174db3b8bf9ed8da 95,557
Standalone, 72 members 547,707 9fd0170f25659f4af86010d3db9b835e6b585f92fd3234ad394fe4590e51395b 90,955

The cap remains 458,752 bytes with a mandatory 2,000-byte reserve. This is a real portable package failure. Individual PR builds and CI do not establish combined acceptance. Independent measurement report: 8c0150f926b03953488116474af897974a988cdfe1443729e65fdb72dff23da9.

The complete source bundle and recovered security derivative were preserved in checkpoint 40, ZIP SHA-256 40d6f78c772eb9bc4bb42dad02daa669477fc4b6997746ea15402ec170d1bc29. The completed build, its independent measurement, security independent review and subsequent owner readbacks are preserved in checkpoint 41, ZIP SHA-256 ded84db44009164ff5e63b76ef0281170d0e949ad174fdede4a7b655f5267e8c.

PR254's new 21befe99a7d48baa3089381595a7ccb29cb00cd8 publication changes research and portal records only. Its separate documentary/decision receiving with residual continuation is received at that scope; no shipped runtime changes or borrowed native, effect, migration or benefit acceptance follow. All six pending-differential dependency blobs still match the prior observed inputs, so that bank was not replayed.

Actual source engineering continues in isolated lanes for authorization-parameter consumption and a contract-preserving native acquisition partition. No result from those unfinished lanes is claimed here. All six original RLGWO decisions remain separate and open; no Pro-exhaustion, Codex, release, merge or issue closure is asserted.

Require an actual bound value or range and reject noncanonical parameter prefixes before they can bypass validation. Preserve the existing parameter and durable-intake owners. Retain three demonstrated false acceptances, add focused regressions, and record the original P06/P17 receiving scope.

theislampill commented Oct 25, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Published R002E P06/P17 consumer correction

Guarded, non-force publication completed on this existing branch:

  • Public head: 326d091e06b7bbef1647b1d97f3bc84c0dae90ee.
  • Tree: 7aae6dde798ffa365a62348917d16691bba693fb.
  • Parent: 45853f9403f5ffaad100df1686fe5320f72e19b7.
  • Exact public head/tree/parent and clean local source parity were read back. The PR remains open and draft.
  • New hosted validation: 40166868874, IN_PROGRESS at the publication read.

The newly recovered original P06/P17 rows led to three actual false acceptances in the existing authorization consumer: a declared parameter with no value/range, one with an empty value/range, and an out-of-scope mixed-case Param.object skipped by value validation. Each original call returned 0 and the success marker. Those failures are retained.

The two-branch repair requires a real constraint and rejects the ambiguous prefix. Both unchanged literal/range positives remain accepted; all three negative predicates now refuse. The existing registered test, extended by three regressions, failed on the old helper and passed on corrected source. It also passed once in the actual PR251 template/fixture context. The earlier security-profile and ordinary-model banks were reused without replay.

The change is exactly three files: existing helper, its already registered test, and an append-only four-work-order ledger entry. Existing #12 parameter-binding and #137 durable-intake ownership remain; the unrelated #84 rehearsal branch is byte-identical and was not invoked.

Independent source/claim review: report 50471125e9af65836f40c8c251da1f769c33e1d4cd92c75bfc291fb16a639f8e, receipt 39c65d2611a25c04cfc5aaf191dd8ac56ffeadb9b4f082d8f042c154598141e1. Actual package/receiving review: report 8507283a7f20c1143fa5b5180cb98507a34b193007964ac4230cf402eba4bf8f, receipt 068f55ed0fe96945ec4399681ca34c09dab6c8f1fdfd6e78569c01ecff4521b8. Both found no mandatory correction and performed no product reruns.

One canonical build on local precursor c337c81699a0b7a92a156e27f71801bb50beb31f, with the identical published tree, produced:

Artifact Bytes SHA-256
Plugin 411,851 1296d8685863f2b9e13f66ea3cf8cc6c431d53eecc3580a080e23ccd577d80ba
Standalone 407,415 86422e85b51663ea82b582364c0592ae6cd29fcb0a671479d5feb947b5751a75

The fixed cap and reserve are unchanged. Four official isolated copies match all 278 archive files in bytes/modes. Six actual installed-helper calls in the plugin and standalone layouts retain the literal positive and both selected refusals. Only the helper and inventory differ from the previously qualified public-f133 archives. These inventories remain bound to the local precursor; they are not relabeled as a build of the later public commit.

Full source/raw/review was saved before qualification/publication in checkpoint42, ZIP SHA-256 a7d6648427f2f7181e90a0f33347970d9798063f6724cd911ccc0f384a00d1cd. Actual package/copy/consumer evidence and supplemental review were saved before publication in checkpoint43, ZIP SHA-256 82879a7ad1e3c93ee4b9bac187a7791e7f045a61a50f5f2303a20e84900ea4ac.

This advances the portable parameter-consumer obligation. It does not authenticate a grant, prove an executed effect, recover approved-policy/original-whole-file custody, qualify private held-outs, or accept P06/P17 or all 60 security properties. All four original PR251 acceptance decisions remain separate and open. The combined package still fails its distinct capacity gate. The next active increments are the R35 acquisition partition/peer correction and the R37 late-target identity discriminator, both still undergoing independent review at this publication cutoff; neither depends on whole R0035 closure.

Check deterministic transaction occupancy before the replacement no-op return. Preserve cheap absent and other-step paths, exact custody refusals and the lock-free observation limit. Add the registered regression and retain original acceptance boundaries.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R0030 correction published: retained same-step custody on the no-op path

Published 3f627c37c9a71404ed876f3d460e5f27f03ed6e2, tree 2ebf96a41c1336eef5aaaa23ac03ece095a51aa3, parent 326d091e06b7bbef1647b1d97f3bc84c0dae90ee, by guarded non-force update. Exact public head/tree/parent and clean local parity were read back.

Concrete defect and smallest correction. Refreshed matching target/candidate bytes returned NO_CHANGE before the existing same-claim/phase/step transaction check. The new baseline reproduced that erroneous success result in both ordinary and required-generation routes despite retained same-step custody. It performed no new effect and deleted nothing; the failure is not relabeled as native false closure or performed recovery.

The helper now calculates its existing transaction path before that return and checks safe parent custody plus exact lstat occupancy. It preserves ordinary no-transaction and unrelated-step cheap paths. Observed same-step occupancy returns the existing CONFLICT_REBASE / PHASE_AUTHORITY_IN_PROGRESS_OR_REPLAY refusal with the exact transaction id. Unsafe custody refuses. It never reads journal JSON as recovery authority, creates a recovery grant, or changes the non-no-op authority/currentness path.

Four files changed: helper, one registered regression case, four lines in this branch's own reference, and the append-only ledger. No foreign combined reference text was imported. Corrected helper SHA 7a13078b9225c8f773695666ddf493c872328cfa890316bb07dae5934d627b63.

Actual discrimination and independent review.

  • Fresh four-predicate baseline retains its two failed same-step outcomes. The unchanged registered regression is RED against the old helper and GREEN against the correction. Its41 retained subprocess records comprise30setup+11helper calls, not41criteria.
  • Independent source review adds one unsafe-parent invocation: symlinked parent with absent exact transaction refuses64 / INTERNAL_CUSTODY_UNSAFE, with the exact transaction id and unchanged full bytes/non-atime metadata.
  • The new case also passes on this branch's receiving source:14captured commands,3.026seconds, no timeout.
  • Source review PASS: report 90d77c85d432d86a79bc80ef0dba00a34a4b91302d4640ee1b57bd6459755ad1; receipt 7701b40d25b702d323fd0462f87460c91febc5aaccb29783bf81c7979955c57d.

The guard remains lock-free. It establishes observed pre-existing occupancy, not atomic exclusion of a transaction created later, including by another cooperating helper. The original capture wrapper's unobserved timeout-handler difference is retained as a limit; all actual cited source executions completed without timeout.

Actual individual package and installed receiving. One canonical build succeeds. Plugin412078 bytes / SHA 7efcd08cbbee7a2ca71acfce5b0598816539206ef495bd4482b27400c70c1301; standalone407659 / 3aff23411a51bada2b8a12a9c70d4d5e0adf48c94415b07ac476be1e2f2f3f10. Both retain the fixed458752 cap and2000reserve, with44674/49093bytes headroom.

Four official isolated staged copies match278archive byte/mode comparisons. One case definition runs once in each of plugin and standalone layouts:20setup+8actual installed-helper calls, outcomes0,0,65,65 in each. Actual paths select installed helper, claim and templates. The v3 refusal retains NOT_EVALUATED generation, null guard, retryfalse and closureNOT_ASSERTED; this is not authenticated fencing.

Package supplement PASS: report 517a0b4058ff8bc46f0e4ec1aab274fa7a6f30cb1d164e76d4b044fa026b7478; receipt 9a81950111c66b517dcbd54237776868ed0639492a6a9640bdfcff58553c19b5. The reviewer reruns no product commands. The actual inventories retain local precursor b3ad1c787dbdb34fec61f79ea1236c134aadb1b3; this public commit has the same qualified tree. No inventory is relabeled and no second-build determinism claim is made.

Durable evidence before publication. Original source/raw is in checkpoint46; the reviewed exact source, independent probe, own-branch raw case and prepared drivers are in checkpoint47, ZIP 0f1e0fccd3b2d0c3e5f0f3fa934b2e31bb6bb4e0f99025ae1b5e89ad054e5433. Actual packages, installed raw results and independent supplement are in checkpoint48, ZIP fd213956050f97d47aed2f1ff0b31827b7dd067c520f1db75076e20e63d22cf7.

Hosted CI 40169256202 is QUEUED on first public readback, not yet successful.

This advances the bounded C03/C05 receiving guard and affected C07 source/package checks. Original C01–C09 and P53/D48-O01 remain separate OPEN decisions. The original unsupported --recover result is preserved; no generic recovery CLI, real reconciliation, downstream postcondition, interrupted-effect recovery, power-loss durability, external exactly-once, native activation or issue closure is claimed. Combined package capacity remains FAIL, and the source-current combined refresh continues.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Current combined integration: qualified R0030 receiving case, retained package failure

The disposable combined candidate is d8ee34984bbb28aedf614b746ed05e59e772a334, tree bdc8cdb5e29f738d31dd7a1b1b62988ef5a8792a, parent e4fc52757d3082d12f17137600034c5ca008e82b. It receives the exact published R0030 helper/test from PR251 3f627c3, the R0033 receiving test from PR253 088809a, and the reviewed current R39 peer population with the strict pending loader. Foreign branches were not changed.

Source composition: independent review verifies all 18 postimages, 15 effective changes, modes and exact preimages. The shared reference receives only the four R30 lines. All thirteen native peers remain repository-only; this admission does not materialize them onto canonical shipped paths or establish native selection. The existing fourteen pending calls are reused at their original projection/read-set scope, with all thirteen fixed reads and four core dependencies unchanged.

Actual affected R0030 check: the first outer attempt failed during setup after six successful commands because the sparse worktree omitted a tracked phase fixture. It made zero mutation-helper calls. That failure is preserved. Restoring the exact committed 4,585-byte fixture changed neither source nor oracle. The corrected attempt completed0 in3.230601seconds with ten setup commands and four helper calls. Outcomes 0/0/65/65 preserve absent/other-step no-ops and refuse ordinary/protected exact-step retained custody. Protected fencing is explicitly NOT_EVALUATED; no recovery, native activation or closure grant follows. This is one unchanged case definition and two outer attempts.

Actual combined package: one canonical build exited1 in11.946913seconds, without timeout.

Artifact Bytes Members Reduction needed including reserve
Plugin 544352 75 87600
Standalone 539749 72 82997

The cap remains 458752 and mandatory reserve 2000. Plugin SHA256 is a90abd89fb3ed04512a4a520cdfd4fa0137272e485ce30df3b8d2ad81185acb3; standalone is 93fc5234cde5779e197000a26a1449e50593dd129b5711897946010cedee6296. Both inventories bind actual d8ee/treebdc8. Independent content/inventory/mode/source checks pass. No members were added or removed; only the helper, reference and inventories differ from the e4fc archives, increasing size225/221bytes. The native peers and repository tests are not package members.

The builder stopped at plugin capacity. Canonical standalone verification, checksum generation, outer artifact checks and final checksum verification did not execute. No oversize installer bypass was attempted. The canonical codec already uses pinned Zopfli method8, and the verifier rejects other methods; no codec or cap weakening was introduced. Individual PR251 package success does not qualify this combined package.

Independent result: source/case/artifact integrity PASS; build/capacity FAIL; complete combined qualification NEEDS_REVISION. Report SHA256 b7b2807f42490dfe0826048f5bc8382bbcbbabf82f21238ec9de7ca1d453d7d8; receipt 886807ccbaefdd7fdeec40e6f5db0015bd6d5d6ec8c804f187c184a1367265d2. Review made no subject replay or rebuild.

Reproducible source and actual evidence:

  • Checkpoint49, ZIP SHA256 1022693ad6cc8dbfe91336bd8516e50a9224f69b769f8a2faad0c78a18544b7c, contains the sealed source proposal, independent source review and evidence/integration38-combined-actual/combined-source.bundle. The 318880-byte bundle has SHA256 5117c645416b264859d40ab8d5a2f9b64a530d0a92737e22fd46183abb7018b2, requires only public f1332a5 and verifies successfully.
  • Checkpoint50, ZIP SHA256 644d5abe5053239c6eb9d1a3d9bd35911371d17e957f95620bef74d0c62119d8, contains both actual attempts, physical fixtures, materialization record, emitted archives, raw build and full independent actual-result review.
  • The direct R39 pending proposal remains PR252 comment6394314167. The conditional R35 partition/profile basis remains PR246 comment6394206590; it is not a direct cbb patch.

The six original acceptance decisions remain separate and OPEN. The package residual remains portable work. A fresh bounded C05 functional rollback episode is being corrected at prospective preflight before its first execution; its preparation GAP is neither a product failure nor recovery acceptance. Continued receiving work does not wait for whole R0035 closure.

Record the actual bounded C05 publication-fault and maintained rollback episode, preserving the first NONVERDICT, the failed mutation result, exact effect prefixes and ordinary-only currentness. Original issue acceptance and native gates remain open.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R0030 C05: observed function after maintained local rollback

Published by guarded non-force update: d14bbd1f99c2688c4d3dfc28f1e7929a8bcf7be8, tree 3d19225ecc828cef9b0a462d4daa60cd4cff8d00, parent 3f627c37c9a71404ed876f3d460e5f27f03ed6e2. Public head/tree/parent and clean local byte parity were read back.

This increment appends the actual recovery evidence to the existing four-issue ledger. Runtime, test and packaged source are unchanged.

Actual observation Bounded result
First attempt Ordinary phase validation refused before publication or fault injection; helper exit64, no structured result, NONVERDICT/GAP retained.
Corrected deterministic attempt Only two phase-format entries and required isolated source/evidence paths changed. Same functional/capture oracles and fault schedule; attempt2 of the same case, no model-actor replay.
Publication boundary Captured candidate configuration and retained original preimage; independent application actually failed on a missing column while CSV data remained unchanged.
Declared I/O failure and rollback Explicit byte-reversible instrumentation raised fixed EIO after maintained publication-journal persistence. Maintained rollback restored the original configuration. Operation remains exit71 / MUTATION_FAILED_ROLLED_BACK / IO_FAILURE.
Actual post-return function Original two-participant summary returned, total40; separate incompatible data-header control still refused. Ordinary currentness token remained valid.
Journal/effect custody Publication journal47-row prefix, saved result73-row prefix, returned live set79 completed observations. Later persistence tails are not claimed in the earlier saved payloads. Intentional authority/result/released-lock/namespace custody remains.

Independent actual review: PASS_BOUNDED for this declared ordinary local predicate, report SHA-256 ea32361ee5e0874c0739bc93c4e0427208533b287781f8f51588a41d107eaf1e, receipt 6aee6c3ad80adb0416b18c61f3eee01a6e98aedaac074132217a8674e87ed9e5. Final append-only ledger review: PASS, receipt c48e3f33beea9f62c0bfa6e7596335a5139ca93074b613cb09a36ebd523362fc; exact old prefix retained,85 additions/0 deletions. No subject execution was repeated by review.

Source, complete actual capture, physical fixture and independent reviews were preserved before publication in checkpoint53,516845 bytes/SHA-256 617d50a8d6494521a011646d8aa27faf8368472ee5fc73bd9e3f1c80ab0fa648. The first NONVERDICT and prospective correction remain in checkpoint52.

Original C05 and C01–C09 remain open; P53/D48-O01 remains separate. This is not unmodified installed execution, natural crash/power-loss evidence, manual UNKNOWN settlement, protected/native authentication, external compensation or exactly-once execution. The failed mutation is not converted to a committed migration or terminal acceptance. The known combined package capacity FAIL is unchanged.

CI readback: predecessor 3f627c37 run 40169256202 SUCCESS; new documentation head run 40172462472 IN_PROGRESS at publication. Existing exact runtime/package qualifications are reused without a documentation-only rebuild. Each of R002C/R002D/R002E/R0030 retains its own acceptance decision.

Bind ordered ordinary replacement inputs to current phase projections and exact physical source, then recheck authority and selected inputs before returning an observation. Refuse stale, aliased, oversized and transaction-occupied inputs without granting effects.

Retain focused RED/GREEN evidence, independent review, installed-layout qualification and current composite receiving limits. Register the new mode in the source-derived helper census.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Published R0030 EH3 increment: ordinary replacement batch preflight

Guarded, non-force publication is complete at 7e7bae8, tree 1b92423aa7e3ea6c48491c0e9543258fbb1b9c92, parent d14bbd1. Remote parent/tree/head and clean local parity were read back. Hosted run 40174993569 is IN_PROGRESS, not a claimed pass.

Implemented behavior

The existing mutation owner now accepts --batch-preflight <batch.json> as a separate observation-only interface. It validates an ordered list of ordinary replacement steps against actual phase projections, exact captured preimage/candidate bytes, physical witnesses, alias/duplicate constraints, current authority and selected phase membership. It refuses oversized manifests, stale inputs and occupied same-step transaction custody, then closes source/authority/selection fences before returning.

The output explicitly grants no effects: OBSERVATION_ONLY, authority NONE, effect authority false, atomic false, later revalidation required and an empty governed-effect set. Existing temporary validator support effects are declared separately. No batch execution, atomic/durable snapshot or external exactly-once guarantee is introduced. All 90 existing function bodies and ordinary execution semantics were preserved; three required relocations remained byte-identical.

Actual qualification and retained failures

  • First source: 15 observations, including two positives and thirteen refusals. Independent review found two manifest-read defects and missed selected-phase membership drift. Three actual first-source witnesses retained their incorrect outcomes.
  • Corrected source: the four focused observations returned 0/64/64/64, with ten top-level commands and no timeout. The unchanged fifteen-case bank was not replayed.
  • One actual ordinary-v2 mutation returned 0/COMMITTED. Its following harness used an overstrong durable-result-equals-live-output assertion and failed. Read-only adjudication established the retained 69-row durable prefix plus six subsequent publication-tail rows in the 75-row live result; no mutation rerun or persistence claim was substituted.
  • The first package command failed at static helper census before any build or installation. The bounded correction recognizes the new mode from its actual top-level parser registration, dispatch and implementation, and adds the complete documented invocation. The corrected census reports 28 helpers / 18 modes; parser-removal and dispatch-removal source controls remain unregistered.
  • The existing test's old 17-mode expectation also failed against that captured census output. Exactly three expectations were updated to 18; the same assertion then passed. No old full helper, route or allocation bank was replayed.

Packages, installed consumers and composite receiving

One canonical build completed successfully on local candidate 2a5de030815dd6a41eca1d3f0570e0a1c25e76c7 / tree000b502724b8e11855b937e54d48e623250bcdf0:

Role Compressed bytes SHA-256 Headroom after unchanged 2,000-byte reserve
Plugin 414,989 c76f2783501d222e9e7c03db2a5fbda867ae41076be4f22d930fd0266beb2b24 41,763
Standalone 410,579 7518f61ac5a40d541524ecbfd673a3203f7642c3de5c03772349f64019bb803e 46,173

The donor cap remains 458,752 bytes. Four official isolated copies passed 278 byte/mode comparisons. One actual two-row preflight through each distinct installed layout returned 0/OBSERVATION_ONLY with unchanged source and physical snapshots.

The final published tree differs from that built tree only in the repository test's mode-count expectation. An explicit package-applicability comparison proves unchanged shipped source, package contract and build/install logic. Those artifacts retain their actual 2a/tree000b source identities; they are not relabeled as builds of this public commit.

A 47-file projection of exact PR255 runtime at 00341e8 plus the proposed EH3 change executed two receiving calls: current ordinary controller 0, then intentional controller-marker removal with its bound ref retained 65/STALE_CONTROLLER_CUSTODY. All source inputs and within-call physical snapshots stayed unchanged. PR255's subsequent 8dd311c changes only the revision-4 release-asset assertion, so these runtime observations remain applicable at their original recorded source identity. A new whole-composite package claim has not yet been made.

Review, custody and acceptance boundary

Final independent review is PASS_BOUNDED, report SHA-256 cb7ca166e593e29f9c9c796b6fefb2d1500137df3d17cfc8f31804bee5c14394, receipt bb3f64f870ecf94e64cc195c8ee540d8e246464180c7b087669b781d6b97ded3. It binds all six final files, retained first failures, actual archives/copies, installed calls and composite receiving observations without product reruns.

Source and evidence were preserved before publication in checkpoint55, ZIP SHA-256 5b89515241ff56e8f5fa55736670b04d940ec6a5eeae46850b537a114aa71b18, 3,605,147 bytes / 410 files. Earlier frozen packets remain retained.

This advances the original EH3 all-target preflight obligation at ordinary portable scope. Ordered execution, protected merge/self-row/bootstrap laws, original historical population fidelity, power-loss behavior, authentic external authority and P53 remain separate. Original C01–C09 and all four original issue acceptance decisions stay open. The append-only integration ledger preserves exact evidence and limitations.

Next: qualify the exact five-file composite receiving proposal under PR255's prospective revision-4 budget, and continue the independently progressing R0033 source-map/history interfaces. No foreign branch was written.

Record the independently assessed original six-call replacement episode, preserved prefix custody, actual refusal and unfinished-step recovery. Keep the observation-only interface and original acceptance limits explicit; no runtime or accepted episode replay.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Published the interrupted R0030 ordered partial-failure evidence after completing independent assessment.

  • Public commit: 3cd0249d4295ebb4a4fd992c7b830ad5a9b6be4c; tree: eb0bdcb8857440e58d5f6568e0b9a4c49a808323; single parent: 7e7bae8de911325d6c64fb5a6e51886cf963d894.
  • This append-only increment changes the maintenance acceptance ledger. Runtime, package, installation source and the accepted observation-only batch-preflight interface are unchanged. Their earlier evidence is reused at its actual source identity.
  • The original episode was recovered intact and was not rerun. Its six helper outcomes are now independently assessed: initial observation; first step committed; second step refused after declared drift; original whole-batch preflight refused its stale first preimage; unfinished second row observed after explicit input repair; second step committed. Step 1 has one application invocation and its target plus eight transaction entries stayed unchanged at every subsequent captured boundary.
  • Original actual packet: 380cffbc747d89335f58de352a4ad999ba9eacd64375a24542db73d2ce4cb93a. Independent actual report: 78e1694fe285918621aa78afeed654bc3daa8d2a491455139f4d9750176a3c87; receipt: 05183cdef9ffc7ce7c20ed72872c132d914bb3726b9d8c0e83c3a92c407ed2e6. Separate publication review: 141a1c44f1f57b5245dd542fc09515e8599f6aadcce2d60b554380286332be99; receipt: 3d844f682d911d2f5ed8ac8dc5c6c0d0670fa61ec87419500dd7d6e04cd389b5.
  • Checkpoint60 preserves the recovered original raw/source; checkpoint61 preserves final reviews and the exact admitted postimage. The significant failed/predecessor attempts remain intact. Local diff check and independent append-only claim review passed; no unnecessary product replay was used for this documentation delta.
  • Guarded non-force update used the exact old head. Independent GitHub readback confirms head, tree, parent and exact ledger blob. Hosted CI 40181460979 is in progress at this readback.

This advances bounded ordinary C03/C05/C06-related effect, recovery and currentness predicates. It does not establish automatic batch execution, aggregate atomicity, durable snapshots, natural power-loss recovery, arbitrary protected-effect compensation, external exactly-once, full C01–C09, P53 or original-work-order closure. The four original commissions remain open. Work continues on source-grounded remaining obligations.

Compare each declared alternative with the actual scalar instead of accepting a concatenated substring. Preserve earlier P06/P17 controls, add the real false-acceptance regression, and retain the original RED and independent bounded review.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002E exact-enumeration correction — qualified donor increment

Published by guarded non-force update: aa3756fa3276f10c3d58ce08c9ec36060530cf55, tree d9df03febd52695e5ec50878b8941412343efd15, parent 3cd0249d4295ebb4a4fd992c7b830ad5a9b6be4c. Fresh GitHub head/tree readback agrees.

The authorization owner previously accepted the scalar report-alpha|report-beta as though it were one member of that enumeration. The correction compares the offered scalar with each exact declared alternative. Both legitimate alternatives still succeed; the joined scalar now refuses, and the existing unknown-value refusal remains. This is a concrete P06/P17 source correction, not acceptance of the entire 60-property security population.

The first false acceptance is retained. The extended existing contract test was RED on the original source and GREEN on the corrected source. The original test body and prior controls remain. Independent source review is FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED (report SHA-256 5eab4b3fa38629e9271e2ab1c71cad38a07fc17ac0e87bd8fd9520de5ecba231).

One build, two strict source checks, official isolated plugin and standalone copies, and four installed helper calls qualify local commit 9ddbe0da48f129e5592b363e7de1b067e06ed5c4 at the same published tree. Package sizes are 415,032 and 410,613 bytes under the existing donor revision-3 limit and reserve. Independent package/installation review is FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED (report e621b2e4e6ce6bb856608a437a3c82cb3991602243b55278a0f941403a2a95c7).

The first package recorder incorrectly asserted empty stderr for the correctly refused canonical negative. Its failure and the captured product streams are preserved. Continuation evaluated those existing streams against the unchanged stderr contract and ran only the two unstarted standalone calls; no completed build/copy/helper prefix was repeated. The separate recorder traceback is not part of the sealed 45-artifact packet, as the review explicitly records.

Raw source and installed evidence plus final reviews were preserved before publication in checkpoint62 (SHA-256 8cf2133333cab4b945caa5a34a799244ca325e3aa1f8536701cc65b6088f35b0). Checkpoint63 preserves publication readback and subsequent review receipts.

Hosted CI 40189883975 was IN_PROGRESS at the latest readback. The preceding R0030 recovery publication's CI40181460979 succeeded. No native discovery, privileged policy input, protected effect, full original-case acceptance, merge, release, or issue closure is claimed. Refs #198; the other original orders and their prior GAP/NONVERDICT boundaries remain open.

Capture input restrictions and Python source, dispatch existing ordinary steps once, and stop on refusal or uncertain live returns with an explicit unstarted tail. Preserve per-step journals without aggregate atomicity, retry or compensation.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Qualified R0030 increment: ordered ordinary replacement consumer

Published by one guarded, non-force update from aa3756fa3276f10c3d58ce08c9ec36060530cf55 to bf0e4831dea9c16d87ce11688e747c8db6173456, tree d5fbef7a34bb2cc611dcd71f01c12b0b91338a79. The branch ref, PR head and exact commit/tree/parent were independently read back.

The earlier original two-step partial-failure episode and its independent assessment remain preserved at their actual identities in the preceding ledger increment. It was not rerun. The already published --batch-preflight remains observation-only.

New maintained functionality

The existing mutation owner now supports --batch-apply <batch.json> for ordered ordinary REPLACE rows using the existing batch input schema.

  • Complete all-target preflight before dispatch. Capture the Python source once and execute ordinary children from that retained buffer.
  • Narrow the existing per-step grant with captured batch input, claim, phase, source, authority, shared evidence, controller and HEAD restrictions. Check those restrictions before the early NO_CHANGE path and again before transaction creation.
  • Dispatch each attempted step once in order. Record the actual exit and lossless stdout/stderr, including byte lengths and hashes.
  • Treat only a matching ordinary v2 COMMITTED or NO_CHANGE return as complete. Duplicate/nonfinite JSON, wrong identity, contradictory exit or absent live return cannot become success.
  • Stop on refusal or uncertainty and leave the remaining rows explicitly NEVER_STARTED. A saved committed result does not manufacture a missing live return.

The aggregate result grants no additional effect authority and is not an aggregate durable receipt. It provides no automatic retry, compensation or multi-step atomicity. Existing per-step transactions retain their own durable records and effect accounting.

Source and adversarial qualification

The first eight-entry source population recorded seven batch invocations, fourteen child attempts, ten completed rows and nine transactions. Those nine include eight live COMMITTED results and one persisted commit whose absent live return remained UNKNOWN. Coverage includes ordered COMMITTED/NO_CHANGE/COMMITTED completion, middle-step target drift, initial all-target preflight refusal, selected-evidence drift, exact phase-byte drift before NO_CHANGE, missing live return, parser identity/JSON/exit negatives, and replacement of the helper path after source capture.

These source episodes deliberately use disclosed derived/instrumented helper copies for drift, observation, missing-return and source-path interventions. They are not described as uninstrumented installed executions. Four existing preflight delta controls and the affected helper census passed. The first Git-free census setup failure and earlier sparse-copy preparation errors remain retained; only the blocked census was continued in a correctly committed disposable fixture, with no completed source population replay.

Source packet: 5357 regular files, manifest SHA256 1abc112cfedb65cfa4b260767d7f9edd2725ce8e4ec0454ed7d4950725078949. Independent source/actual review: PASS_BOUNDED, report 12460111703d20853e0e2b29a7e3e883de9a6bcecb2516c6f4bff30676de482f, receipt a13b4fb1368ecce6cee1512a065001157689084fa655b6c1ad5e4e913d606d10.

Direct installed qualification

One clean-source build, two strict artifact checks and two official isolated copies completed. All 139 installed files match archive bytes and modes. Four additional direct installed calls used the exact maintained helper without instrumentation:

Layout Current three-row fixture Separate initial-row2-drift fixture
Canonical plugin Exit0; COMMITTED / NO_CHANGE / COMMITTED; two transactions Exit65; REFUSED; zero attempts/transactions; all rows NEVER_STARTED
Standalone Exit0; COMMITTED / NO_CHANGE / COMMITTED; two transactions Exit65; REFUSED; zero attempts/transactions; all rows NEVER_STARTED

Installed totals: six attempted/completed rows and four transactions. Both refusal fixtures are physically and byte-identical before and after the invocation. Every saved committed result retains its exact effect prefix; each corresponding live result adds the existing six publication effects. NO_CHANGE creates no transaction or effect set.

All 33 original command returns and full streams are retained, including fixture Git/ordinary claim setup. The aggregate runner's actual stdout/stderr and exit0 are also retained. There were no retries. Package packet SHA256: 94dc75c6b1a85e2029d3f195187f98f5300eccb2d8f2e04a4220e014918e3ac7, 368 files /2,652,992 bytes.

Independent package/installed review: PASS_BOUNDED, report e414573b8ac894b60396ec13a63e13c5736040aa0b08c1b2c2a171a360b61d9a, receipt 4f1480a7fd352cb0ca09cc3d8b0eefc78d9eb2a213274ef665c933cebde0336c. The exact ledger append is supported and preserves its complete parent prefix and original evidence limits.

Artifact Bytes SHA256 Margin after the unchanged 2,000-byte reserve
Canonical plugin 420,048 0865a41264916f2027562b449779263c47ad5b845918d3a26c797068e48657c2 36,704
Standalone 415,622 aed533b6714c26ffbe3657a0a39d0990707ae2d022f35f47c7f7243c86feafab 41,130

The donor cap remains458752. These archives were built at local candidate c26fba72222588810138e3e75ef5b6c309716c12, whose tree exactly matches this public commit. Their inventories retain that actual local commit identity; they are not relabelled as builds from later public commit metadata.

Source/raw evidence and final independent reviews were preserved before publication: checkpoint64 22046a75f2a30e4886cb3e3452862208336cf6984651e2f1e6df823fee048e94; checkpoint65 388a97e093595e329ae56243f3fa60d9b38a5e71626d5cca3455d17615cc68bc; final review checkpoint67 7e0c6a6cae3ac095c980cb028a1b9f619cbf28fcbe59ffca16b019eaefa67647.

Original acceptance and ongoing work

This advances maintained ordered ordinary operations, partial-failure stopping, explicit unstarted-tail accounting, source/input custody and live-return uncertainty. It does not establish arbitrary protected-effect compensation, natural power-loss recovery, universal exactly-once behavior, aggregate atomicity, full C01–C09, separate P53, or original issue acceptance. The R002C case-B GAP and earlier NONVERDICTs, R002D warehouse NONVERDICT/version-specific ActiveGraph evidence, and R002E original sixty-property population retain their meanings.

The preceding head's CI40189883975 completed SUCCESS. New-head CI40194358224 is IN_PROGRESS at receipt readback. The six-work-order commission continues; this is not an exhaustion or transfer declaration. PR255's later receiving of this optional API remains separate. No other-owner branch, main merge, release or original-issue closure was performed.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002D: content identity and delivered view now use one acquisition

Published d3cf2d465a474bd6ed2af7fb704678cdb6b8bc24, tree 35ca2bd6cb816ec42514855b388f4c76d366066b, parent bf0e4831dea9c16d87ce11688e747c8db6173456. This is one guarded non-force update to the existing branch. Ref and a separate second PR read confirm the new head; the first immediate PR read returned the old head and is retained as a stopped readback guard. No second update was issued.

The existing scripts/dogfood-evidence-broker.py::read_target previously hashed one file acquisition and reopened the path for the delivered read/search view. The original interleaved observation recorded digest(A) but emitted B. That original parent exit 1 and both owner exits 0 remain preserved.

The correction captures one byte buffer, hashes it and derives the delivered view from its strict UTF-8 decoding with the existing universal-newline behavior. Authority, path and journal validation are unchanged. The two corrected first calls each make one byte read and no text-file read, record A and emit A; the interleaving still occurs and leaves the target as B. This does not claim concurrent-writer snapshot isolation or complete output delivery.

Actual affected qualification

  • The original baseline is bound to local c26fba72222588810138e3e75ef5b6c309716c12. The fixed episode used isolated postimages against clean public/local bf0 and is not relabelled as execution of this new Git commit.
  • The exact paired harness was reused without editing its retained original implementation-prediction fields or coherence predicates.
  • Eight new focused controls pass: stable/interleaved read, interleaved literal search, UTF-8/BOM and mixed newlines, line numbering, case-sensitive no-match, empty input, and strict malformed UTF-8 refusal with no output or completed sink.
  • One affected maintained-test invocation passes, retaining all original 50 broker CLI commands. The original test body is byte-preserved apart from 20 diagnostic-path substitutions across seven filenames; outputs now use its temporary directory, with optional create-once evidence retention.
  • No baseline or completed qualification replay occurred. The separate recorder preparation AST error remains preserved as a pre-execution failure.
  • Root git diff --check and the unchanged durable-identity scanner both pass.

Independent source/actual/ledger review is FINAL / PASS_BOUNDED, report SHA256 c5a729e0149ec03353901e5a2312556b3ca588ca526003527b9ff609c773954a, receipt 7061fc6439b5194bebd7b269599089ebf052b117ad255f9645383eff3091465e. The actual packet binds 439 files / 2,294,111 bytes, SHA256 4e7d38aebe24cc759a8003fe2a50a2440683cf91a850bf4bfdc1cc00930352ab.

A separate independent mechanical-adoption/static-receiving review is FINAL / PASS_BOUNDED, report 9161b654ece44bf5769899453b0a25d67054871d25654ba7f4cd1d7dfde8acd5, receipt 72870b6ef2ee46341827437edebc94c03cc7daf4e286ed96f87837520356fd6c. Its 421 read-only checks confirm the exact two postimages and the sole 3,865-byte ledger addition, with all 108,661 earlier ledger bytes preserved.

Package and acceptance boundaries

These three repository paths are outside the shipped payload. All 70 canonical and 67 standalone non-inventory members are byte/mode equal to the preceding qualified payload. Generated inventory would bind a new Git identity, so no earlier archive digest or installed execution is relabelled and no new installed-broker claim is made.

This advances bounded ordinary acquisition and record coherence. The focused calls use declared precondition stubs and plain argument sinks; maintained keys/journals are artificial test authority. The 72-property R002D contract, version-specific ActiveGraph evidence, warehouse NONVERDICT and authentic self-dogfood prerequisites remain separate. R002C case B and earlier NONVERDICTs, R002E's 60-property decision and R0030 C01–C09/P53 retain their original judgments.

Source, raw evidence, independent reviews and exact adoption were preserved before publication in checkpoint 71, SHA256 c53eacff45848a901b4685e9f75d460118b362eb7b074567eb2cabf69d7f07b0.

Hosted validation 40197954890 is IN_PROGRESS at readback. The preceding bf0 run40194358224 was still in progress at its latest separate read. A source- and byte-qualified two-path receiving proposal for PR255 is separate; no foreign branch, merge, release or issue closure is included.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002D increment: terminal hosted CI received

Run 40197954890, job 121182791424, completed SUCCESS for donor head d3cf2d465a474bd6ed2af7fb704678cdb6b8bc24.

The retained job log records actual checkout c35bcde1d85b1d7333c05806e0a8af7659a5f358. Independent Git API readback confirms its tree is exactly the reviewed donor tree 35ca2bd6cb816ec42514855b388f4c76d366066b, with parents main e78f7cb21af4197d490f10bc95917a4c75f748aa and that donor head. This is exact-tree hosted execution through the synthetic merge; it is not literal donor-commit execution.

The complete raw log is 396,730 bytes, SHA256 e9cf7408d3e1e567da8b9aaede27ace8bd2c41ffb79e0ed2f5cfbbf776239989. Its terminal verify-package: ok is recorded at 2026-10-25T14:17:41.1506748Z. The original single-read RED, fixed source/affected-bank review, immutable ledger history and separately qualified PR255 receiving proposal remain at their actual identities. This hosted regression result does not certify any of the four original RLGWOs or supply native self-dogfood/acceptance authority.

Preserve known completed rows and genuinely uncalled tails. Count an attempted dispatch before invoking the child, and report the selected row as UNKNOWN when its start or return cannot be established.

Retain the original failure, corrected execution, package qualifications and incomplete R002C evidence at their actual identities. Correct the unpublished temporary-directory description.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R0030 dispatch-exception correction: interrupted increment recovered and published

One guarded, non-force expected-head update advanced this existing PR from d3cf2d465a474bd6ed2af7fb704678cdb6b8bc24 to 3e7c1cd4a5c8aa01262f413a23e401132c7d0555, tree 84a32e8790d42391a837a2ca82f1a5d9046441da. The public ref, PR head, commit/tree/sole parent, all four affected file buffers and modes, and exact local checkout parity have been verified. The PR remains open and draft.

Behaviour and preserved original evidence

The existing ordered replacement executor is retained. Its dispatch-exception path now prepares the captured input first, counts the attempt immediately before the child invocation, and reports the selected exceptional row as UNKNOWN with dispatch_started=null. Known earlier results remain recorded. The genuinely uncalled tail stays NEVER_STARTED/false. An unavailable return is not treated as proof that the operation never began.

The original failed episode is preserved: the second child actually committed, while the old parent reported only one attempt and falsely labelled that selected row never started. Original packet 2d40d374828f0ddc95a2105a3ffa710bc1b7d40feb305c8e04ddff571102eaf5 and its independent RED assessment were not replayed.

The recovered first corrected episode retains two selected maintained invocations, sixteen inner commands and five child invocations. The normal control preserves COMMITTED / NO_CHANGE / COMMITTED; the exceptional control retains two actual committed children while the parent truthfully knows only one completed return: attempted 2, known-completed 1, selected UNKNOWN/null, uncalled tail NEVER_STARTED/false. Both selected test invocations returned zero. Actual packet: 3ac2a788ed45c9c27703cc83062880a85137e095bc793ebbe246c9c250b701a6.

Review, package and source identities

  • Recovered local candidate 2cdc0aa256a3995dc1d68b3766d700795ae9f988, tree ef6e91444df0f5c9ac5f2c2387444a0a245bf4e1, contains the originally qualified helper/reference/test and append-only evidence.
  • Recovered source/raw review: FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED, report SHA-256 505f482fbecd9e35bc5d4e86edfd7a1ed5f4f05abfab1c2c08c8671e6658e9b2. Recovered adoption/package review: FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED, report f4d333975aa326589dccf3cb10d7ed86db623c0e8880d5f5953dfdb186871b77.
  • The original build, two strict artifact checks and two official isolated copies completed successfully. Plugin: 420,201 bytes, SHA-256 78389c94d72a972914029525d024cc85ebe22a8b9afde8d125a87dbe722d2621. Standalone: 415,772 bytes, SHA-256 e79393e5981dab4b1d13a7dd397da3852d760978cb08de575bac1899855e26ad. All 139 installed files match archive bytes and modes, under the unchanged donor cap 458,752 and reserve 2,000. Installed behavioural invocations in this package episode: zero.
  • Fresh independent recovery review verified the original 592-file R0030 packet, corrected 251-file packet and preceding 282-file R002C packet. It identified one unpublished wording error: one of the three added temporary directories contains another directory. The precise wording now states that the three directories contain no regular files. This sole ledger correction is local successor 00e1cf5349aa0d0c0a8c2e4b3aba06b38c58572b, whose tree is exactly the published tree. Runtime, reference and test bytes remain unchanged. Fresh review: FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED, report f28f68790456b37e7c9ec8c49481f5ffc05bc6cafef94e16f111ed99ab81009e.

The package inventories retain their actual 2cdc0aa execution identity; they are not relabelled as builds at the documentation successor. A fresh readback verified all 260 package-packet members, 31 review members and 139 installed files without rebuilding or replaying product cases. Checkpoint82 preserved the recovered suffix and fresh review before publication: SHA-256 c523d9ed764ead5e3cbfc6b1c7b5edf0623e07a2d8c5522adef2a735366cfee9.

Hosted run 40218102702 is in progress at this receipt; no terminal result is claimed yet.

The preceding R002C partial episode remains NONVERDICT and its expired-permission arm remains unstarted. Later physical-directory discrepancies remain UNKNOWN. Nullable-field compatibility with arbitrary external Boolean-only consumers is unproved. This publication does not close original C01–C09/P53, any original RLGWO, native authority/Stop/JOIN, protected recovery, mainline integration or release.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R002E P06/P17: reject malformed range specifications

New source-bound correction on the existing PR #251. Public head: 92f7f388654c159a99e0f3db9b7e369304e90310; tree de72731f07aba016e698794cd6ad8878ce6b206c; sole parent 3e7c1cd4a5c8aa01262f413a23e401132c7d0555. Exactly three changed paths: existing authorization helper, its maintained test, and a reviewed append to four-rockstar-integration.md. Existing mode 100644 is preserved for all three. The update is guarded, non-force, against the exact prior head.

Defect and correction

An ordinary inert range discriminator observed the old consumer accepting runtime value 7 under both valid 1..10 and malformed 1..not-a-bound..10. Both first calls returned 0 with identical 84-byte success output. The old range arm kept only the first and last endpoints and discarded the interior. The original 0/0 episode remains preserved; it was not replayed.

The correction adds exactly one 47-byte guard requiring the parsed endpoints and one delimiter to reconstruct the entire specification before the unchanged numeric comparisons. Helper: 17,837 bytes, SHA-256 ce41e7306b7b11f5dde4844fd753ec77965ec04f15f0d8dfef4e9684a7c9d2e3. Scalar/enum behavior, including the earlier accepted exact-enumeration correction, and established AUTHORITY DRIFT classification remain unchanged.

The first corrected source pair returned 0/1 on the exact original inputs, followed by one affected maintained-test success: 0/1/0. The earlier 8,843-byte executable test prefix remains; twelve new controls cover ordinary/signed/zero endpoints, malformed interior segments and immediately outside values. Test SHA-256 807ecb005c1bd69eaa4ecf13608bb2caef1b9c96b1792a9c08f22b54f595011f.

Independent source/evidence/ledger review is FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED: report e90e41a4fc497e375cfdd7e19d44def4123d329dfd05019fedbd1dd65dfed27a, receipt 9cd39ccca10a4301297c0e92efe6e65dc2fc7c1e56f8320122e30e7b290aaf2a. It checked 236 predicates, all 49 manifest members, 32 candidate/original bindings and 21 retained original RED/input artifacts. The exact 1,885-byte ledger append was supported unchanged.

Exact adoption, package and installed qualification

Actual build/adoption commit 2bc2f31d2076df30a4c44a9e69a8306d3ebaf70f, tree de72731f07aba016e698794cd6ad8878ce6b206c, remains the identity in the package inventories and runtime records. It is not relabeled as the later public commit.

Completed exactly one top-level official build, two additional explicit strict archive checks, two successful official isolated copies and four direct installed-helper calls. Each installed layout accepted the valid range and refused the malformed range: 0/1/0/1. All 139 installed files match archive bytes and modes; 137 non-inventory archive entries independently match canonical source. All 1,397 tracked source-path records remained equal: 946 materialized files and 451 explicit skip-worktree absences.

Artifact Bytes SHA-256 Headroom after 2,000-byte reserve
Canonical plugin 420,215 44cbad643d09eeae5662173ab871d3960bc4c057951510bce93a07583b59767a 36,537
Standalone 415,785 c581d2e3ac0863eff3c498e680bfa918169d4ef8bc796c46ec303c5428922ed5 40,967

The donor cap remains 458,752 bytes per role. PR #255's prospective revision 4 cap is not applied here.

Independent adoption/package/installed review is FINAL/PASS_BOUNDED, with no unresolved finding at that scope: report ccb01c746c7e24edd43f5aa80d8c916d5b95c6a3cb22a4284188ef60044f07d1, receipt 951bc08796078558b08e801a1d4cc39d1bd2f326c200b0ced39c740addd57e48. Exact package packet fb314a4903a0a75807c2659b484ff44930ebd128f99a3a4cdf73667a643a819b binds 219 files.

Preserved administrative and negative outcomes

The first recorder stopped after four Git reads because it wrongly assumed every indexed path was materialized. All 451 missing paths are explicitly skip-worktree; no build or product call had begun. A separate recorder preserved absent paths and all materialized byte/physical guards.

The first plugin installer then correctly refused a nonexistent disposable host root, exit 1 with 52-byte stderr, before copying. That refusal remains retained. The suffix created the required disposable directories/sentinels and ran only the blocked/unstarted work. The successful build and strict-check prefix was not rerun. There are three installer invocations including that refusal, two successful copies, and 16 recorded package-stage command outcomes overall. A review-only one-space checksum-format expectation also remains recorded; the canonical writer uses two spaces, and a separate narrow ten-check review resolved the reviewer error without product replay.

Proof limits and continuation

This advances ordinary P06/P17 parameter-consumer correctness. It does not supply the original approved policy/private crosswalk, an authenticated principal/issuer/grant, a protected effect, native admission or an original R002E acceptance certificate. The original census of 60 properties and 117 sources and all other five work-order contracts retain their exact scopes. No source-bank replay, real-home install, foreign branch write, merge, release or issue closure occurred.

Public ref/head/tree/files were read back. Hosted validation: run [40220032842](https://github.com/theislampill/IMPLEMENTAUDIT.md/actions/runs/40220032842) is IN_PROGRESS; no terminal success is claimed yet. The separately published R0030 correction and its own run 40218102702 retain their identities and evidence. Combined-source receiving remains with the PR #255 owner.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

R0030 dispatch-exception correction: terminal hosted qualification

The existing publication is now qualified by terminal hosted run 40218102702, job 121243538156, conclusion SUCCESS, completed 2026-10-25 18:33:31 UTC. The Verify package contract step succeeded and the complete retained log records the terminal verify-package: ok marker before job cleanup.

The actual checked-out commit was the synthetic merge 42ac6817947a2f579afa0ecb7fa4a02feca2227a. Its verified tree is 84a32e8790d42391a837a2ca82f1a5d9046441da, exactly the published R0030 donor tree. Its actual parents are main e78f7cb21af4197d490f10bc95917a4c75f748aa and donor 3e7c1cd4a5c8aa01262f413a23e401132c7d0555. This establishes hosted execution of the exact donor tree through that merge checkout, not literal donor-commit execution.

The complete decoded job log is 396,729 bytes, SHA-256 a6e133ebfbc774930b6ad5837f663d06e0bd77b97a9b6bf661cb242970c6e3df. An earlier log read while the job was still active returned BlobNotFound; that response remains preserved separately and was not treated as a failed product test. An initial local text save added one trailing LF; that version is retained separately, and the exact log above was decoded from the saved complete response.

The correction preserves completed preceding effects, records a selected exceptional operation as UNKNOWN with unresolved start/outcome, and leaves genuinely uncalled later rows NEVER_STARTED. The original failing episode, corrected episode, independent source/adoption review, and exact package/installed-copy evidence remain retained without replay of those isolated experiments.

PR #251 has since advanced through the separately reviewed R002E correction to 92f7f388654c159a99e0f3db9b7e369304e90310, tree de72731f07aba016e698794cd6ad8878ce6b206c. Its hosted run 40220032842 remains a separate source/result obligation; this R0030 result does not substitute for that run. No issue closure, native authority acceptance, main merge or release is claimed.

This branch has not been deployed

No deployments
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant