Skip to content

TASK-1100: Resolve the GWTC-5 O4b selection-function boundary once - #1681

Merged
gladunrv merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1100-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control
Jul 30, 2026
Merged

gladunrv merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1100-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control

Conversation

@gladunrv

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

PR Kind

  • Canonical task PR
  • Task proposal PR
  • Microtask PR
  • Task closeout PR

Primary Reference

Canonical task PR:

  • Task ID: TASK-1100
  • Task File: tasks/TASK-1100-resolve-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control.yaml

Branch Name

  • agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1100-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control

PR Title

  • TASK-1100: Resolve the GWTC-5 O4b selection-function boundary once

PR Lifecycle

  • Branch pushed
  • Draft PR opened by agent or manual PR creation commands provided
  • Post-PR review command run or manual review command provided if no PR number is available
  • Marked ready for review after CI passes and review agent returns MERGE_OK, or manual ready command provided

Summary

Audit the official O4b boundary and prove that the current O4a+O4b sensitivity artifact cannot yield an auditable O4b-only normalization.

Changed Files

  • tasks/TASK-1100-resolve-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control.yaml
  • docs/reviews/gravitational_waves/gwtc5-o4b-selection-control-task1100.md

Linked Repository Memory

  • Hypothesis:
  • Experiment:
  • Task / Proposal / Queue: TASK-1100
  • Result:
  • Claim / Knowledge:

Validation Commands

  • python3 -m pytest -n0 tests/test_data_redistribution_declarations.py tests/test_docs_links.py
  • python3 -m physics_lab.cli validate-repo . --strict --fail-on-warnings
  • git diff --check

Scientific Claim Impact

  • No claim promotion.

Result Artifact Impact

  • No committed result artifacts changed.

Output Routing

  • Task verdict: STOP_NO_AUDITABLE_O4B_CONTROL
  • Canonical destination: docs/reviews/gravitational_waves/gwtc5-o4b-selection-control-task1100.md
  • Review tier: none
  • Gate A status: not_applicable
  • Gate B status: not_applicable
  • Claim impact: No claim promotion.
  • Knowledge impact: No knowledge promotion.
  • Limitations / blockers: The official O4b start conflicts with the pinned
    sensitivity README by 172800 seconds, and the artifact does not publish
    O4b-only generated-count, analysis-time, or mixture-weight normalization.
    No HDF, event row, posterior, strain, search trigger, or astrophysical value
    was inspected.

If this PR contains AGENT_PUBLISHED or AGENT_VALIDATED artifacts, keep the qualifier explicit and document Gate A/Gate B status.

Agent / Contributor Metadata

  • Contributor ID: gladunrv
  • GitHub username: gladunrv
  • Agent tool: Codex
  • Model/version if known:
  • Task ID / Proposal / Queue: TASK-1100
  • Branch: agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1100-gwtc5-o4b-selection-control
  • Human reviewer: gladunrv

Maintainer Review Notes

  • Review the validation commands and exact-SHA PR diff before merge.
  • Keep any task status transition at REVIEW_READY until maintainer closeout.

@gladunrv
gladunrv marked this pull request as ready for review July 27, 2026 10:47
@gladunrv
gladunrv added this pull request to the merge queue Jul 30, 2026
Merged via the queue into main with commit 96e9960 Jul 30, 2026
8 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant