Skip to content

TASK-1092: Synchronize campaign state from current evidence - #1675

Closed
gladunrv wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1092-current-evidence-refresh
Closed

gladunrv wants to merge 2 commits into
mainfrom
agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1092-current-evidence-refresh

Conversation

@gladunrv

@gladunrv gladunrv commented Jul 25, 2026 •

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

PR Kind

  • Canonical task PR

Primary Reference

  • Task ID: TASK-1092
  • Task File: tasks/TASK-1092-sync-campaign-state-after-july-terminal-gates.yaml

Branch Name

  • agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1092-current-evidence-refresh

PR Title

  • TASK-1092: Synchronize campaign state from current evidence

PR Lifecycle

  • Branch pushed
  • Draft PR opened
  • Post-PR review command run
  • Marked ready for review after CI passes and the review agent returns MERGE_OK

Summary

Clean successor to closed PR #1649. This branch starts from current main (087dffd2) and synchronizes only campaign, mission, status, and public science surfaces that are materially stale against merged evidence. It does not transplant the former snapshot wholesale and does not add generated task views.

The synchronization records the July terminal gates for OQMD, Lattice QCD, CHARA/DEBCat, quantum-size, ThermoML, dimensional-analysis, FRB, nuclear prediction, and calibration-only campaigns. Research mode now recommends READY TASK-1081 and reports six READY science tasks across five surfaces.

Changed Files

  • tasks/TASK-1092-sync-campaign-state-after-july-terminal-gates.yaml: current-evidence contract and REVIEW_READY lifecycle state.
  • campaign_profiles/_catalog.yaml and nine materially stale campaign_profiles/*.yaml: canonical campaign state, blockers, and next routes.
  • missions/current.yaml, docs/current-missions.md, and docs/status.md: current mission routing and portfolio status.
  • docs/campaigns/README.md, docs/campaigns/fresh-physics-data-axes.md, and six campaign pages: bounded public scientific wording and next result paths.
  • No docs/task-views/*.md files are included; post-merge automation owns them.

Linked Repository Memory

  • Hypothesis: unchanged; no hypothesis promotion.
  • Experiment: EXP-0024 / OQMD benchmark state referenced, no experiment file changed.
  • Task / Proposal / Queue: TASK-1092; routes synchronized to current TASK-1075/1076/1077/1078/1079/1080/1081/1082/1083/1084/1088/1089/1090/1091/1095/1098/1099/1101/1102 states.
  • Result: RESULT-0030, RESULT-0031, and RESULT-0032 summarized without editing result artifacts.
  • Claim / Knowledge: CLAIM-0009 canonical reviewed calibration-memory state synchronized; no claim or knowledge file changed.

Validation Commands

  • python3 scripts/generate_campaign_catalog.py --check
  • python3 scripts/apl_check_mission_drift.py
  • python3 -m pytest -n0 tests/test_campaign_registry.py tests/test_campaign_curator.py tests/test_mission_control.py tests/test_mission_freshness.py tests/test_docs_links.py (68 passed)
  • python3 -m physics_lab.cli validate-repo . --strict --fail-on-warnings (0 errors, 0 warnings)
  • git diff --check

Scientific Claim Impact

  • Claim files changed: no
  • Novelty Classification: n/a
  • Claim status impact: none; this PR only synchronizes already-canonical claim state into campaign and mission surfaces.

Result Artifact Impact

  • No workflow runs were needed for this synchronization.
  • Committed results/ artifacts were left untouched.
  • All result wording is bounded to the canonical review tier, verdict, and source limitations already present on main.

Output Routing

  • Task verdict: SYNC_COMPLETE_REVIEW_READY
  • Canonical destination: campaign profiles/catalog, mission/status documents, and materially stale public campaign pages
  • Review tier: none (portfolio synchronization; no new scientific artifact)
  • Gate A status: not applicable
  • Gate B status: not applicable
  • Claim impact: no transition; CLAIM-0009 state is mirrored from canonical memory
  • Knowledge impact: no new knowledge artifact
  • Limitations / blockers: no new source access, reveal, score, success, cross-database, population, morphology, or uncertainty claim is introduced

Agent / Contributor Metadata

  • Contributor ID: gladunrv
  • GitHub username: gladunrv
  • Agent tool: OpenAI Codex
  • Model/version if known: GPT-5
  • Task ID / Proposal / Queue: TASK-1092
  • Branch: agent/gladunrv/codex/task-1092-current-evidence-refresh
  • Human reviewer: gladunrv

Maintainer Review Notes

  • Review this PR as the clean current-main successor to closed TASK-1092: Synchronize campaign state after July terminal gates #1649.
  • RESULT-0032 remains a bounded within-OQMD negative/control result, not a materials discovery claim.
  • CHARA RESULT-0031 remains inconclusive and identity-gated.
  • Quantum-size remains held underpowered with no independent route.
  • ThermoML authorizes bounded extraction only; no scoring or threshold shopping.
  • FRB remains a registered point-score/rank prediction surface with no reveal or success claim.
  • Nuclear remains trigger-only pending a source-version reveal.
  • Maintainer review and merge remain required; the agent will not merge this PR.

@gladunrv
gladunrv marked this pull request as ready for review July 25, 2026 13:42
@gladunrv

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Maintainer review: closing this snapshot as stale; please prepare a clean successor from current main after the queued TASK-1091 fixture lands.

The deterministic exact-head review is green, but the content snapshot is no longer current: it still routes TASK-1091 as a READY no-fixture action, does not incorporate the merged TASK-1100 STOP_NO_AUDITABLE_O4B_CONTROL outcome, and its 22 campaign/mission files now materially diverge from current main. Merging or mechanically rebasing this broad snapshot could overwrite newer campaign state.

Required successor scope: start from current main, ingest the final TASK-1091/TASK-1100 canonical outcomes, update only materially stale campaign/mission surfaces, regenerate the catalog, and rerun mission-drift plus targeted campaign tests. The canonical TASK-1092 remains READY on main, so no task is lost by closing this stale attempt.

@gladunrv gladunrv closed this Jul 30, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant