Skip to content

About

This project aims to identify cost-effective alternatives to expensive medications using data analysis, clinical evidence, and automation tools. The first use case focuses on comparing ketamine to esketamine for the treatment of treatment-resistant depression.

Resources

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Repository files navigation

💊 Affordable Drug Alternatives: A Comparative Analysis

A summary comparing originator drugs with their lower-cost alternatives for key medical conditions.

Static Chemical Similarity Demo

This repository also includes a static GitHub Pages demo for preprocessed compound similarity exploration:

  • Frontend source: Changjin/frontend/
  • Static data: Changjin/frontend/public/data/
  • Deployment: GitHub Actions builds Changjin/frontend/dist
  • Published URL: https://cccccjin.github.io/Affordable-Drug-Alternatives/

🧠 Treatment-Resistant Depression (TRD): Esketamine vs. Ketamine

Esketamine (Spravato®) vs. Ketamine (IV Infusion)

Condition Context: Treatment-Resistant Depression (TRD) affects patients who have not responded to at least two different antidepressant trials. In the U.S., this represents an estimated 30-40% of the general MDD population.

💰 Cost Comparison (United States)

Therapy Details Induction Cost (USD) Estimated Annual Cost (USD)*
Esketamine Spravato® nasal spray ~ $4,720 – $7,080 ~$20,000 – $30,000
Ketamine Racemic, IV Infusion (Cash-pay) ~ $2,100 – $6,000 ~$5,600 – $16,000

Note: Annual cost is estimated based on a standard treatment protocol, including an initial induction phase followed by a full year of maintenance sessions (approx. 34 sessions/year for Spravato® and 16 sessions/year for IV Ketamine).

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Annual Cost Comparison: Esketamine vs. IV Ketamine

Global Depression Prevalence
Global Depression Prevalence Map from OECD
Source: OECD Mental Health Data

💪 Multiple Sclerosis (MS): Ocrelizumab vs. Rituximab

Ocrelizumab (Ocrevus®) vs. Rituximab (Biosimilars)

  • Ocrelizumab Brand: Ocrevus®
  • Rituximab Biosimilar Brands Include: Truxima®, Ruxience®, Riabni™, Hanlikang®, Delituo®

Condition Context: Relapsing-Remitting MS (RRMS) is the most common form, accounting for about 85% of diagnoses in the US. Primary Progressive MS (PPMS) is less common, affecting 10-15% of patients.

💰 Annual Cost Comparison by Region (All Figures in USD)

Region / Payer Ocrelizumab Cost (USD) Rituximab Biosimilar Cost (USD) Notes
United States (Medicare) ~$69,949 ~$11,759 Based on Average Sales Price (ASP).
Significant savings with biosimilar.
United States (Medicaid Net) ~$47,671 ~$5,893 Net price after mandatory rebates.
Highest percentage savings.
Sweden ~$12,400 ~$2,400 Based on estimated national tender prices.
Rituximab is the far cheaper off-label option.
United Kingdom ~$12,700 ~$3,500 Ocrelizumab cost is net price after NHS discount.
Rituximab cost is for off-label MS use.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Annual Cost Comparison: Ocrelizumab vs. Rituximab Biosimilar (US)
Cost comparison chart for Ocrevus and Rituximab

Global Number of People with MS (Prevalence)
Global MS Prevalence Map from Atlas of MS
Source: Atlas of MS - Epidemiology

🦠 COVID-19: Molnupiravir vs. Fluvoxamine

Molnupiravir (Lagevrio®) vs. Fluvoxamine

  • Molnupiravir Brand: Lagevrio®
  • Fluvoxamine Brands: Primarily available as a generic drug. A common brand name is Luvox®.

Condition Context: These oral medications are used for the early treatment of mild-to-moderate COVID-19 in non-hospitalized adults who are at high risk for progression to severe disease. The goal is to prevent hospitalization and death.

💰 Cost per Treatment Course Comparison (All Figures in USD)

Drug Region Estimated Cost per Course (USD) Notes
Molnupiravir
(Lagevrio®)
United States ~$700 Based on initial US government procurement price.
United Kingdom/EU ~$300 - $500 Price reflects national negotiations and procurements.
LMICs (via MPP) ~$20 - $40 Generic versions available via the Medicines Patent Pool license.
Fluvoxamine
(Generic)
Global ~$10 - $30 Mature, widely available generic drug.
Used off-label for COVID-19.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Global COVID-19 Epidemiological Trends
WHO COVID-19 Dashboard showing global cases
Source: WHO COVID-19 Dashboard

Methodological Note: For acute infectious diseases such as COVID-19, market size assessment is critically dependent on incidence (the rate of new cases) over prevalence, as incidence directly reflects the flow of new patients requiring therapy. In the current era, official case counts are significant undercounts due to reduced routine testing, making them unreliable for direct analysis. A robust estimation must therefore leverage epidemiological models that integrate more reliable data streams, such as hospitalization rates and wastewater surveillance. Given the inherent uncertainties, the market potential should be presented as a scenario-based forecast (e.g., low, medium, high) rather than a single, definitive point estimate.


🧬 Cushing's Disease: Korlym vs. Mifepristone

Korlym (mifepristone) vs. Generic Mifepristone

  • Korlym® Brand: A specialty, high-cost formulation of mifepristone.
  • Generic Mifepristone: The same active ingredient, widely known for its use in medical abortion (Mifeprex® was the original brand), and available as a low-cost generic.

Condition Context: Cushing's disease is a rare endocrine disorder caused by prolonged exposure to high levels of the hormone cortisol. Korlym is specifically approved to control hyperglycemia (high blood sugar) in adult patients with Cushing's who are not candidates for surgery or have failed prior surgery.

💰 Annual Cost Comparison (United States)

Therapy Details Estimated Annual Cost (USD) Notes
Korlym® Specialty brand for Cushing's ~$200,000 - $500,000+ An ultra-orphan drug with extremely high pricing, dependent on dosing.
Mifepristone Generic version ~$3,000 - $10,000 Cost is for daily, off-label use for Cushing's, calculated from the low price of generic tablets. A stark contrast to the branded version.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Market Comparison: Korlym® vs. Generic Mifepristone

Comparison Metric Korlym® (for Cushing's Disease) Generic Mifepristone (Primarily for Medical Abortion)
Primary Indication To control hyperglycemia in patients with Cushing's syndrome (a rare disease). Medical termination of early pregnancy.
Patient Population Size Very Small. A few thousand patients treated annually in the U.S. Very Large. Hundreds of thousands of users annually in the U.S.
Pricing Strategy Ultra-High Price. Leverages its "Orphan Drug" status for premium pricing. Low Price. Priced competitively as a generic drug.
Market Size Driver Price Volume

Chart 1: Estimated Market Size (USD)

Data Source: DelveInsight Cushing's Disease Market Report

Estimated Annual Market Size Caption: This chart illustrates the estimated annual cost and market size for Cushing's Disease treatments.

Chart 2: Prevalence Comparison

Data Source: DelveInsight Cushing's Disease Market Report

US vs EU Prevalence Comparison Caption: A comparison of diagnosed Cushing's Disease cases in the US vs. the EU4 & UK, broken down by gender (2024 data).


⚕️ Nephropathic Cystinosis: Procysbi vs. Cystagon

Procysbi (cysteamine) vs. Cystagon (cysteamine)

  • Active Ingredient: Both drugs are different formulations of cysteamine bitartrate.
  • Key Difference: Procysbi® is a delayed-release formulation dosed every 12 hours. Cystagon® is an older, immediate-release formulation dosed every 6 hours.

Condition Context: Nephropathic cystinosis is a rare, inherited metabolic disorder where the amino acid cystine accumulates in cells, causing widespread tissue and organ damage, particularly to the kidneys and eyes. Cysteamine therapy helps to deplete these toxic cystine levels.

💰 Annual Cost Comparison (United States)

Therapy Details Estimated Annual Cost (USD) Notes
Procysbi® Delayed-Release (12-hr dosing) ~$300,000 - $900,000+ Priced at a significant premium for the quality-of-life benefit of not requiring middle-of-the-night dosing. Cost is highly weight-dependent.
Cystagon® Immediate-Release (6-hr dosing) ~$50,000 - $150,000 The older standard of care. While still expensive as an orphan drug, it is far less costly than the newer formulation.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Chart comparing the market size of Tepezza, Krystexxa, and Uplizna in 2023

Source: According to the Amgen 2023 Annual Report, the company completed its acquisition of Horizon Therapeutics, the developer of Procysbi, in October 2023.

Note: Cystagon's market share is continuously shrinking due to patient conversion to its successor, Procysbi, leaving it to serve a niche population with access challenges and an estimated market size in the tens of millions.

Chart comparing the annual incidence of Nephropathic Cystinosis in Europe and the US

Data extracted from: Orphanet Epidemiology Data


🔬 MS & Rheumatic Disorders: H.P. Acthar Gel vs. Corticosteroids

H.P. Acthar® Gel (ACTH) vs. Synthetic Corticosteroids

  • H.P. Acthar® Gel: A purified preparation of adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), a biologic with a controversial pricing history.
  • Corticosteroids: Generic, synthetic steroid hormones like prednisone (oral) or methylprednisolone (IV).

Condition Context: Both are used to treat acute exacerbations (flares or relapses) in MS and some rheumatic disorders by powerfully reducing inflammation. Synthetic corticosteroids are the standard first-line therapy. Acthar Gel is typically reserved for patients who cannot tolerate or do not respond to high-dose steroids.

💰 Cost per Treatment Course Comparison (All Figures in USD)

Therapy Details Estimated Cost per Course (USD) Notes
H.P. Acthar® Gel ACTH biologic ~$45,000 - $200,000+ One of the most expensive drugs in the US by vial cost (~$45k). A full course of treatment is extremely costly.
Corticosteroids Generic (e.g., IV Solu-Medrol) ~$500 - $2,000 Includes the cost of the generic drug and infusion services. Represents the inexpensive standard of care.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

Bar chart comparing the annual market size of H.P. Acthar Gel vs. Synthetic Corticosteroids
Source: Mallinckrodt plc FY 2024 Financial Results. Corticosteroid market is an estimation.

Methodological Note: The estimated annual market size for synthetic corticosteroids in treating MS flares, ranging from $128 million to $510 million, is calculated by multiplying the U.S. RRMS patient population (~850,000) by an average annual relapse rate (~0.3) and a per-treatment course cost of $500-$2,000.


Grouped bar chart comparing the annual incidence of MS and Rheumatic Disorders in the US vs. Global

Data Sources:

Note: The Y-axis uses a logarithmic scale to visualize data spanning multiple orders of magnitude.


🔄 Urea Cycle Disorders: Ravicti® vs. ATX-018

🔬 Comparative Analysis: Ravicti® vs. ATX-018 for Urea Cycle Disorders

This document outlines a comparison between Ravicti® (glycerol phenylbutyrate), an established nitrogen-scavenging agent, and ATX-018, an investigational mRNA therapeutic for the treatment of Urea Cycle Disorders (UCDs). UCDs are a group of rare genetic diseases that cause life-threateningly high ammonia levels in the blood (hyperammonemia). While Ravicti® helps manage the symptoms by providing an alternative pathway to remove ammonia, ATX-018 is designed to correct the underlying genetic cause.


Mechanism of Action

Therapy Type How It Works
Ravicti® Nitrogen Scavenger Provides an alternative metabolic pathway for the body to excrete nitrogen, effectively removing toxic ammonia. It manages symptoms rather than curing the disease.
ATX-018 mRNA Therapy (Investigational) Delivers messenger RNA (mRNA) to the patient's liver, enabling the cells to produce the correct, functional enzyme they are genetically missing. Aims to restore normal urea cycle function.

💰 Annual Treatment Cost Comparison

The cost landscape for UCD therapies shows a significant price difference between the older generic standard of care and newer, branded options. The cost of a potential gene-based therapy like ATX-018 is expected to be exceptionally high.

Therapy Details Estimated Annual Cost (USD) Notes
ATX-018 Investigational mRNA Therapy N/A In clinical development. As a potential one-time or infrequent gene-based therapy, it is expected to have an extremely high upfront cost if approved.
Ravicti® Branded Nitrogen Scavenger ~$500,000 - $800,000+ The advanced, branded standard of care. Represents a very high, lifelong medication cost.
Sodium Phenylbutyrate Generic Nitrogen Scavenger ~$100,000 - $250,000 The older generic standard. Significantly cheaper but associated with a high pill burden and poor palatability.

📊 Epidemiology & Market Context

Market Size Analysis

The market for UCD treatments is dominated by high-cost therapies, with significant potential for new entrants that can address the underlying cause of the disease.

UCD Market Size

  • Ravicti® (Current Market): The global market for Ravicti® was approximately $600 million in 2023. This reflects its value as a leading single-product therapy.
  • ATX-018 (Potential Market): As an investigational drug, its potential market is the entire UCD treatment space, which was estimated at $1.33 billion in 2024. This represents the total market new therapies can compete for.

Sources: Transparency Market Research, Dataintelo

Prevalence & Subtypes

Urea Cycle Disorders (UCDs) have an estimated incidence of 1 in 8,500 births. However, this figure is considered an underestimate, as many cases may go undiagnosed [1].

Ornithine Transcarbamylase Deficiency (OTCD) is the most common subtype. A literature review of pregnancies in women with UCDs reported the following distribution of cases [2]:

  • Ornithine Transcarbamylase Deficiency (OTCD): 59.6%
  • Argininosuccinate Synthetase Deficiency (ASSD): 25.0%
  • Carbamoyl Phosphate Synthetase I Deficiency (CPSD): 9.6%
  • Argininosuccinate Lyase Deficiency (ASLD): 5.8%

References

  1. National Urea Cycle Disorders Foundation. (n.d.). What is a UCD? Retrieved from https://nucdf.org/about-ucd/what-is-a-ucd/
  2. Stepien, K. M., Langendonk, J. G., Dao, M., et al. (2024). The management and clinical outcomes of pregnancies in women with urea cycle disorders: A review of the literature and results of an international survey. Journal of Inherited Metabolic Disease, 47(6), 1239-1259. https://doi.org/10.1002/jimd.12695

🫁 Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: Standard-Dose vs. Low-Dose Pembrolizumab

💊 Pembrolizumab: Standard vs. Low-Dose Regimens

  • Standard-Dose Pembrolizumab: An anti-PD-1 monoclonal antibody administered at the FDA-approved fixed dose, such as 400 mg every 6 weeks.
  • Low-Dose Pembrolizumab: An evidence-driven, dose-optimization strategy using a reduced amount of the same anti-PD-1 monoclonal antibody, such as 200 mg every 6 weeks.

🏥 Clinical Context: Treating Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC)

Both regimens are for the treatment of Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC), where Pembrolizumab is a foundational immunotherapy. It is a first-line standard of care, particularly for patients whose tumors express the PD-L1 biomarker. The standard dose is the approved, widely adopted regimen. Low-dose strategies are being actively investigated based on clinical data suggesting that PD-1 receptors can be fully saturated at lower concentrations, potentially offering similar efficacy with significant cost reductions and a lower risk of toxicity.


💰 Annual Cost Comparison by Region (All Figures in USD)

Comparison based on a standard-dose of 400 mg every 6 weeks versus a hypothetical low-dose of 200 mg every 6 weeks.

Region Standard-Dose Cost (USD) Low-Dose Cost (USD) Notes
United States ~$191,000 - $205,000 ~$95,500 - $102,500 Represents one of the highest global list prices.
Canada ~$112,000 ~$56,000 Based on national health system pricing and review.
United Kingdom ~$115,000 ~$57,500 Net price after National Health Service (NHS) discounts.
Germany ~$89,000 ~$44,500 Price reflects national negotiation outcomes.
Japan ~$44,000 ~$22,000 Represents one of the lower prices among developed nations.

Note: Costs are estimates based on publicly available list prices and pharmacoeconomic data, not net transaction prices. Actual costs vary by country, payer, and negotiated discounts.


📊 Epidemiological Landscape & NSCLC Estimates

Global Cancer Incidence

Lung cancer is the leading cancer by incidence globally, highlighting its significant public health burden.Global Cancer Incidence Ranking: Top 15 Cancers in 2022:

Global Cancer Incidence Ranking

Source: IARC GLOBOCAN 2022

Lung Cancer Incidence in Key Countries

The following chart details the absolute numbers of new lung cancer cases in 2022 across selected developed nations.

Lung Cancer Incidence by Country

Source: IARC GLOBOCAN 2022

Estimating the Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer (NSCLC) Burden

General lung cancer statistics include both small cell (SCLC) and non-small cell (NSCLC) types. Based on data from the American Cancer Society, NSCLC accounts for approximately 80% to 87% of all lung cancers cited from American Cancer Society. By applying this ratio to the total incidence, we can estimate the number of new NSCLC cases.

Estimated New NSCLC Cases in 2022

NSCLC Case Estimates Table NSCLC Case Estimates Bar Chart

Disclaimer: Figures are estimates based on the methodology described. Actual case numbers may vary.


💉 Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria: Ravulizumab IV vs. Subcutaneous

Ravulizumab IV vs. Subcutaneous Administration

  • Intravenous (IV) Ravulizumab: A long-acting C5 complement inhibitor administered by a healthcare professional every 8 weeks.
  • Subcutaneous (SC) Ravulizumab: The same C5 complement inhibitor formulated for weekly self-administration at home using an on-body delivery device.

Condition Context: Both formulations are used for the long-term treatment of Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria (PNH) to prevent hemolysis (red blood cell destruction). The standard IV infusion requires patients to visit a clinic every two months. The subcutaneous option offers greater convenience and autonomy by allowing patients to treat themselves at home, which improves patient-friendliness. A study in the British Journal of Clinical Pharmacology found that dose reductions of up to 64% are possible while maintaining therapeutic exposure. The study also notes that the subcutaneous administration is non-inferior to the intravenous formulation in efficacy.

💰 Annual Treatment Cost Comparison (All Figures in USD)

Therapy Details Estimated Annual Cost (USD) Notes
IV Ravulizumab Intravenous Infusion every 8 weeks ~ $500,000+ Represents the standard of care. Cost is based on the high list price of the drug and includes administration/infusion service fees.
SC Ravulizumab Subcutaneous Injection every week ~ $500,000+ Drug acquisition cost is comparable to the IV version annually. Reduces costs associated with clinic visits and infusion services but adds costs for the delivery device.

Key Driver: Product Differentiation

In a market with multiple competing drugs of similar efficacy, a more convenient method of administration is a core differentiating factor and provides a significant competitive advantage.

Epidemiological Data: A Look at the U.S.

According to a report by the U.S. Census Bureau, the epidemiological data for PNH in the United States is as follows[1]:

  • Prevalence: Approximately 12 to 13 cases per million people.
  • Incidence: An estimated 5.7 cases per million person-years.

📊 Market Size & Growth

The following data outlines the financial outlook for the global PNH treatment market[1]:

  • 💰 Current Market Value (2023): $3.9 Billion
  • 📈 Projected Market Value (2032): $10.1 Billion
  • 🚀 Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR): 11.2%
  • 🗓️ Forecast Period: 2024 – 2032

*[1]: Data cited from the Global Market Insights industry analysis report: Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria (PNH) Treatment Market


🩸 Blood Cancers: Standard CAR-T vs. Low-Cost "In-House" CAR-T

Standard CAR-T vs. Low-Cost "In-House" CAR-T

  • Standard CAR-T (Kymriah®, Yescarta®): Patient T-cells are collected, frozen, and shipped to a centralized corporate lab for genetic engineering (viral vector based). The process takes several weeks.
  • Low-Cost "In-House" CAR-T: Patient T-cells are engineered on-site at the hospital's lab (non-viral vector or simplified viral methods), often in a "closed system." The process can be completed in a few days.

Condition Context: Both models produce Chimeric Antigen Receptor (CAR) T-cells to treat aggressive blood cancers like Multiple Myeloma, Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma, and Acute Lymphoblastic Leukemia. Standard CAR-T is the established, FDA-approved method but suffers from extremely high costs and long production times. As highlighted in the MIT Technology Review, the "in-house" or "point-of-care" model aims to solve these issues, making CAR-T therapy faster, radically cheaper, and more accessible to patients.

💰 Cost per Treatment Course Comparison (All Figures in USD)

Region/Country Standard CAR-T (Kymriah®, Yescarta®) Low-Cost "In-House" CAR-T (Estimated) Key Considerations
USA ~ $370,000 - $530,000+ Significantly lower than commercial prices, but specific data varies by institution. As the main market for commercial CAR-T, the US has the highest prices, which do not include additional medical costs such as hospitalization and management of side effects.
Europe Prices vary by country due to national health insurance negotiations, generally slightly lower than in the US. Academic centers are actively developing to significantly reduce costs. The bargaining power of national health systems with pharmaceutical companies is key to price differences.
China ~ $150,000 - $180,000 (RMB 1.2 - 1.29 million) Costs for some clinical trials or local production may be lower. Several CAR-T products are already on the market domestically, and competition has led to prices lower than in Europe and the US, but they are still considered "sky-high" drugs.
India N/A (Commercial products are not yet widely available) ~ $30,000 - $40,000 The indigenously developed NexCAR19 shows a very competitive price, aiming to improve accessibility for patients in low and middle-income countries.

📊 Epidemiological Data & Visualizations

This section presents a comparative analysis of the incidence rates for several types of cancer across the globe, focusing on major economies.


Multiple Myeloma

Below are visualizations of the global incidence of Multiple Myeloma. The primary visual is a bar chart comparing rates among major economies, followed by a global heatmap of the Age-Standardized Rate (ASR).

Comparison of Major Economies (Multiple Myeloma) Bar chart comparing the incidence rates of Multiple Myeloma in major economies

Global Heatmap (ASR) Global heatmap showing the Age-Standardized Incidence Rate for Multiple Myeloma in 2022


Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma

This section visualizes the global incidence of Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma, led by a detailed bar chart and supplemented by a world heatmap.

Comparison of Major Economies (Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma) Bar chart comparing the incidence rates of Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma in major economies

Global Heatmap (ASR) Global heatmap showing the Age-Standardized Incidence Rate for Non-Hodgkin Lymphoma in 2022


Leukemia

This section visualizes the global incidence of Leukemia, with the primary focus on the bar chart comparison, followed by the global heatmap.

Comparison of Major Economies (Leukemia) Bar chart comparing the incidence rates of Leukemia in major economies

Global Heatmap (ASR) Global heatmap showing the Age-Standardized Incidence Rate for Leukemia in 2022


Data Source

All data and original visualizations are from the IARC Global Cancer Observatory. For more details, please visit: https://gco.iarc.who.int/today/en/dataviz/maps-heatmap

About

This project aims to identify cost-effective alternatives to expensive medications using data analysis, clinical evidence, and automation tools. The first use case focuses on comparing ketamine to esketamine for the treatment of treatment-resistant depression.

Resources

Stars

0 stars

Watchers

0 watching

Forks

Releases

Packages

Contributors

Languages